UFO LED or HPS 250w

malignant

Well-Known Member
But as anyone who both knows how to grow weed and has used both HPS and LED (CFLs too actually) knows, LED light kicks ass.


If I'd had known LEDs had such a bad rep, I'd have taken pics of past crops done with LEDs. I've got a grow going now that I'm logging and have posted a couple videos of it as well. Once its done, you'll see buds like you wouldn't believe. I've got a Jack Herer that, when its done, will look like its dipped in powdered sugar... -Loki

alright, i wanna see big tight buds, i know 2 ufo's over 2 plants isn't shit and it sucks ass, but if you've figured out the secret engineering hasn't show us some pics of big buds like we get from hid, and how you put it together and i'll try it out the same way you did it.
 

smppro

Well-Known Member
Funny, you need to do some more reading there Sherlock. If you had paid attention, you'd see the bud that is pictured in that grow log is from an outdoor grown GDP. I helped a buddy harvest and thats what I got out of it.

And if you follow the fine details of the grow, you might notice I started out taking pictures with my cell phone. This is the first grow I've kept a log of, and IMHO I think its a pretty decent grow log. I bought a 10 megapixel camera and I even posted 2 videos. You can bet I'll show the finished buds, once they're done. Until then, you guys can speculate on LEDs and in 2 months, I'll show you how wrong you were.

In the meantime, since I can't make my plants grow any faster than they grow, if someone wants to point out an LED grow that looks shitty, please do so and we can talk about that whats right and wrong about that particular grow. I've never seen a LED setup with UV, other than mine. I've seen lots where the lights are home made... a dozen 5watt LEDs 4 feet above the plants, no mylar, probably feeding the miracle-gro. And the guy was thrilled when his plants stretched 10cm in one day... Holy Fuck! And he was pleased as punch at that, "amazing growth" he said... unfrigginbelievable...

2 grams/watt is hella good. I never broke 1 gram/watt with my HPS, but I didn't do any training or ScrOGing, and that's where you really see the difference.

I honestly get a kick out of you LED doubters. You're like the straights who think pot will turn people into pycho killers... Those who have been growing a long time will remember CFLs coming of age. This is the same thing, just different characters. HID growers like to scare the noobs away from other lights. Its probably for the best when it comes to LEDs because there aren't many decent comercial units yet. You can grow bud with a LED UFO, but it ain't going to be any where near a 400 watt HPS, but that's because of its design. You'd do just as well with 15watts of LEDs in the same foot print that the UFO has, because 80% of that light is going to be wasted.

-Loki
Ok i can go with that, my opinions are based off the UFO being the standard for LED, which i am apparently wrong. Your right most people have them to far away from the plants and not enough reflection. Im a firm believer that light saturation makes all the difference. Maybe i just haven't applied LEDs since i discovered that. I use to use a 400w HPS, now i use 4-42watt cfls, in a 24inx16inx32in box(i have 2 of these running), when i open the door to that little box the light reflecting out of there is pretty inpressive, the buds dont have to be as close either. So hopefully you have figured it out and will have some great results to show us, good luckbongsmilie
 

SpruceZeus

Well-Known Member
Well, what is it about LEDs that makes them bad for growing pot? You said they were good for other plants, but not pot. You stated that as a fact, yet the best you've come up with to back it up is "I aint never seen no good LEDs grows". Lets talk about the light. Did you know todays Cree dye LEDs will put out 4x the photons per watt of the best HPS? What about wavelengths? You HPS growers are always bringing that up when someone mentions flowering with MH HIDs.

From the pics of your grow room, and lack of mylar, I'd say your gardening skillz still need some work. This isn't my first LED grow. I know they work and I know how they work best. My colas aren't huge, but that has more to do with the grow style (ScrOGish) than the lights.

You mention you need lots of air movement to strengthen your stalks. If you had more blue, your plants wouldn't be so stretchy and that wouldn't be an issue. But of course, if you didn't have a lot of air flow, your plants would fry...

That Jack Herer has 16 branches, plus the top. Each one will produce about a dry 1/8th... This one may do less, because I sprayed 2 branches with ionic silver to force it to make male flowers... so I can make some feminized seeds... I'm hoping to still hit the 2 oz mark though...

I know you want to reply, "but show me buds!". If you do, you will end up on my ignore list because you clearly aren't reading/understanding my posts. I'm posting a grow log now, there will be lots of pics of the harvest, but you have to wait... If that's not good enough for you, then that's too bad. LEDs don't make the plant grow any faster... It won't stop my buds from growing if you don't believe in them... I'll get just as high weither you like LEDs or not, lolz...

Seriously though, get some mylar. Proper reflection and you can double the amount of light your plants get... And it adds side light, which will lower your red/far red ratio and your plants will stretch less...

-Loki
Yeah you're totally right, because i use panda plastic, which is less than half the cost of mylar, doesnt crinkle, and is rugged enough to be held up with staples, I dont have a fucking clue. I'm interested in things that work well with low maintenance and a low price, not alot of hyped up garbage, which is obviously where we differ.
Get fucked man, you talk a big game, but when it comes down to it, you're just some asshole whos growing one gnarly plant. Its actually kind of surprising that you have the balls to keep throwing claims at me.
"If i had more blue..."
Like the blue spectrum the 400w mh i use to veg has? for someone with so much knowledge you really are not very smart are you?
"My colas aren't huge, but that has more to do with the grow style (ScrOGish) than the lights."
It may be true that your colas are smaller because you have a Scrog going, but i've seen plenty of Hid growers with HUGE buds in screen of green, why not yours?
You're also right that i want to come back with "show me the buds" I dont even care of they're your buds, just any fat buds grown with LEDs would be sufficient to prove to me that it can be done. I'm not trying to argue that you're a shittier grower than me (although you seem bent on proving the opposite), just that your lights aren't as useful as mine

LEDS are better than HIDS!!! YOU stated that as a fact, yet the best you've come up with to back it up is lots of heresay, some videos that wont load, and a grow journal with a tiny little plant with next to no bud that you're using for breeding ( i give you the benefiet of the doubt that you'll come out with feminized seeds, but i woundlt be half surprised to see you end up with 200 hermie beans). Which for the record looks like shit and could have been grown under a couple t8s without any problems.
Im done with this shit, i was hoping to see something redeeming about LEDs, all i have learned is that you're more interested in cutting me down than you are in preaching the good word. So enjoy your x-mas lights, im gonna go bask in the warm, comforting glow of my archaic dinosaur lamp and the multiple ounces of bud growing under it. If you're the best representative LED growers have its gonna set the whole movement back years. Because in the end, people (specifically me) dont give two shits if you tell me you grew alot of tight nugs under leds, IF I HAVEN'T SEEN THEM, THEY ARE WORTHLESS AS AMMUNITION!
I've read claims of 90w panels being equivilent to 400w hps'. Even if this is true (which i doubt) Why the F would someone pay $400 dollars for this? my 400w hps cost me $89 including reflector. MY 400w Mh $89, hell, my 1000w hps was only $250. So pretty much i got all my lights (one i dont even need to use anymore) for the price of one commercially available possible equivilent to a 400. Maybe you have some secret recipee for an amazing $75 panel that works wonders, but as of yet, i haven't seen any wonders, or even anything close to what an average joe grower can get with a single 400 or even 250 hid. This is obviously not going to be the experience that changes my mind though, cause instead of trying to make a case based on solid anything you're more concerned with petty shit!
Good luck hiding your grow from your mom and getting those 2oz, i'm gonna go smoke a gigantic blunt that won't even put a dent in my bag thanks.
I hope noone is gullible enough to listen to the bullshit you spew!
Having said that, i wish you no ill, and if you have some evidence of effective LEDs i'd still love to see it.
 

BigBudBalls

Well-Known Member
I'm mainly worried about heat. I'm sure the 250w hps would gay way hotter than the 90w led.
quote]

And a nite-lite will generate less heat then the LED.
Whats your point?

There is no free lunch with lights. You are gonna generate a bunch of heat to get good lights & buds.
 

Loki7

Well-Known Member
Having said that, i wish you no ill, and if you have some evidence of effective LEDs i'd still love to see it.
Really, that mighty big of you. I don't wish you any ill either... well, maybe a bit. But that's just my karma assessment. You're kind of a dick, but *yawn* Whatever man. I'm not here to impress you or get you to use LEDs...

You think MH has a lot of blue in it do you? Pfft... More than your HPS anyway, lol...

I said I was going to post pics of the harvest, but again you go with the 'show me the buds'... You're a broken record... I'm doing the grow log with videos even. If I'm wrong, you'll know it in 2 months. But I've done this before and I know it works. I can't understand what your major malfunction is Pile... You are arguing something I know for a fact works. I've done it several times, yet you dill holes see some shitty LED grows and we never hear the last of it. You have ZERO details about the grows and you're sure the problem was the lights.

I've said if you want to point out a shitty LED grow, I'd be more than happy discuss what was wrong with them. But you don't. Why is that? You seem to have seen lots of them. Lets see you link us one with complete details where they're doing everything else right...

If those buds were as big as your colas get, that sux for you. I've seen colas grown twice as big with the amount of lights you're using. I have an excuse for small colas. I'm working with about a foot of grow room. Let's see you try and grow something that big in an 18 gal tote...

-Loki
 

Loki7

Well-Known Member
alright, i wanna see big tight buds, i know 2 ufo's over 2 plants isn't shit and it sucks ass, but if you've figured out the secret engineering hasn't show us some pics of big buds like we get from hid, and how you put it together and i'll try it out the same way you did it.
Follow the grow log and you'll see exactly what my buds look like...

There is no secret. I keep my lights close to my plants. Use lots of mylar and add UVA to the Red/Blue when I flower... That's it...

-Loki
 

Loki7

Well-Known Member
I'm mainly worried about heat. I'm sure the 250w hps would gay way hotter than the 90w led.
quote]

And a nite-lite will generate less heat then the LED.
Whats your point?

There is no free lunch with lights. You are gonna generate a bunch of heat to get good lights & buds.
Wrong... LEDs can run so they are barely warm to the touch. If your LEDs are hot, you're over driving them. You'll get more light for a little bit then they'll slowly get dimmer and dimmer...

-Loki
 

Loki7

Well-Known Member
Ok i can go with that, my opinions are based off the UFO being the standard for LED, which i am apparently wrong. Your right most people have them to far away from the plants and not enough reflection. Im a firm believer that light saturation makes all the difference. Maybe i just haven't applied LEDs since i discovered that. I use to use a 400w HPS, now i use 4-42watt cfls, in a 24inx16inx32in box(i have 2 of these running), when i open the door to that little box the light reflecting out of there is pretty inpressive, the buds dont have to be as close either. So hopefully you have figured it out and will have some great results to show us, good luckbongsmilie
UFOs are junk. Too much light in too small a foot print. And they cost way too much... and they break... and they only have red/blue LEDs...

-Loki
 

Dutch1976

Well-Known Member
If LED's were any good, 50 different companies would be shoving the proof down our throats. Fact is no can show proof of a big badass plant grown with LED's. If I'm wrong, prove it.
 

Loki7

Well-Known Member
If LED's were any good, 50 different companies would be shoving the proof down our throats. Fact is no can show proof of a big badass plant grown with LED's. If I'm wrong, prove it.
"If I'm wrong, prove it." *yawn*

Again, I'm doing the grow log. I will prove it. Can we get few more people to say "lets see proof"? I'll put this reply on my personal notepad thing and will just copy and paste it from now on... I'm working on my "proof" right now... In 2 months it will have finished growing and you can all see the final results.

As for "shoving proof down our throats", no company is going to show there lights growing pot. WTF? Even places where its halfway legal they show grow systems with tomatoes and shit...

I came here because some decent growers from CannabisCulture came here after the shitty mods banned them. I was hoping this place was a little more up on things. Lights do more than provide energy for the plants. The wavelengths you use and when and how you use them can trigger the plants to grow in ways HIDs growers just can't understand. Its like that picture of a vase that is also 2 faces looking at each other... Grow with HIDs and you can see the vase; grow with LEDs (the right way) and you see the faces too...

Well, in 2 months you'll see...

-Loki
 

malignant

Well-Known Member
word, i look forward to it.. led's are somethin i have little understanding, so it's something i have hopes for but are not yet financially secure enough with to experiment at this time.
 

BigBudBalls

Well-Known Member
]Grow with HIDs and you can see the vase; grow with LEDs (the right way) and you see the faces too...

Well, in 2 months you'll see...

-Loki
Poor explanation of the analogy.
And 2 months where? veg? flowering? And additional lighting with CFLs or *anything* else?
 

Loki7

Well-Known Member
Poor explanation of the analogy.
And 2 months where? veg? flowering? And additional lighting with CFLs or *anything* else?
*sigh* Read the grow log and you'll know. Jesus, you people need to be spoon fed everything don't you? No wonder you guys don't know dick about lights...

-Loki
 

BigBudBalls

Well-Known Member
*sigh* Read the grow log and you'll know. Jesus, you people need to be spoon fed everything don't you? No wonder you guys don't know dick about lights...

-Loki
Ain't joining a site just to see the crap grow. Seen enough LEDs fall way behind HIDs for the full term.

Don't know dick about lights. Cute. Been in optics for over 20 years. 10 on high powered CO2 lasers (cuts 1 inch steel no prob and as a service engineer, *never* an operator) and a couple on optic coatings, and a few other lesser jobs. Yeah, no optical background. LOL!!

Enjoy your lack luster over price production.

unsubscribed, tired of people trying to justify the wasted money they spent on snake oil.
 

Loki7

Well-Known Member
word, i look forward to it.. led's are somethin i have little understanding, so it's something i have hopes for but are not yet financially secure enough with to experiment at this time.
I completely understand some, most, people like HIDs... I don't care what people grow with, I just hate seeing someone spreading misinformation. I'll be glad when this grow is done. I've about had it with dumbshits acting like they have even the slightest clue about LEDs when all they've seen is fucking utube videos. A bunch of armchair gardeners... Same fucking people who lol at noobs using miracle grow. I got a buddy who smoke a lot of Cali green bud in the 70s and 80s grown with miracle grow. He's got polariods of fucking plants 10 feet tall and nearly as wide... Yeah, there is much much better these days, but in a pinch MG and some potash and you can grow pounds...

Okay, so I've said my peace about LEDs. I'm not going to beat this horse any longer. Follow the grow log and decide for yourself whats what...

-Loki
 

malignant

Well-Known Member
*sigh* Read the grow log and you'll know. Jesus, you people need to be spoon fed everything don't you? No wonder you guys don't know dick about lights...

-Loki
dude it requires a login to look at your shit, if your going to post here why not have a journal here too.. would it be so much to cut and paste?
 

Loki7

Well-Known Member
Ain't joining a site just to see the crap grow. Seen enough LEDs fall way behind HIDs for the full term.

Don't know dick about lights. Cute. Been in optics for over 20 years. 10 on high powered CO2 lasers (cuts 1 inch steel no prob and as a service engineer, *never* an operator) and a couple on optic coatings, and a few other lesser jobs. Yeah, no optical background. LOL!!

Enjoy your lack luster over price production.

unsubscribed, tired of people trying to justify the wasted money they spent on snake oil.
Well, I'm not reposting it for some dipshit like you, so you don't get to see it.

And your post shows exactly what you don't know about lights. Lasers, eh? You know what a laser that can cut 1 inch steel has to do with growing.... Dick. You've been doing it for 20 years and you think it relates to growing? That's like saying, I can rebuild an engine, so I'm a race car driver... wrong.

-Loki
 

Loki7

Well-Known Member
dude it requires a login to look at your shit, if your going to post here why not have a journal here too.. would it be so much to cut and paste?
There's got to be over 100 posts... its like 300+ with comments... I didn't know you had to join... That sucks. Sorry...

Does anyone know if StonerForums.com is the same way? I'm thinking about heading over that way to see what the other former CC growers are up to...

-Loki
 

Loki7

Well-Known Member
Just notice your sig Balls...

"The Temporary Relief Assistant Trailer Park Supervisor"

Now I get it... sorry man. I don't normally make fun of the handicapible. I'm sorry if I offended you. kiss-ass

-Loki
 

malignant

Well-Known Member
no worries curiosity got the best of me, why do your lights phase out, from blue to red then off.. wouldn't you have a constant photo period rather than intermittent?
 
Top