Regular or Femenized?

s1dth3k1d

s1dth3k1d

Well-Known Member
So it's the million dollar question.. regular or feminized? I was considering regular bc u get more seeds and I was gonna try the birth control germination method to maybe make it a female. Anybody had any luck with that? Or have an opinion of feminized vs regular? I'm only gonna be doing about 3 plants at once.

Thanks guys :joint:
 
It's been my experience reg seeds you have a 50/50 chance of females. Add in the 50/50 chance they germ your looking at low odds. Fem seeds at least give you 80/20 germ and female plants.
 
I like fems but I scrog. I don't worry about cost as it's only a one-off. I clone from there.
 
I suppose if you can't plant a couple extra, assuming that two will be male, then you may as well do femmed seeds. Just know that there's no guarantee against hermies, and they have a higher rate of hermying due to the actual process of making female seeds - but that's a technicality; no need to worry...it's usually a trait that's been bred out by the time banks will sell them...just if you make your own they have a tendency to hermie a lot.
Which strain / bank you looking at?
:leaf:
 
Be aware that feminized seeds can be unstable and too much stress to the plant can cause them to hermie. The non-fem'd seem to take a lot more stress.
 
s1dth3k1d said:
So it's the million dollar question.. regular or feminized? I was considering regular bc u get more seeds and I was gonna try the birth control germination method to maybe make it a female. Anybody had any luck with that? Or have an opinion of feminized vs regular? I'm only gonna be doing about 3 plants at once.

Thanks guys :joint:
Click to expand...

Please - expound on this birth control a little more. I need a good chuckle.
 
Opm said:
Be aware that feminized seeds can be unstable and too much stress to the plant can cause them to hermie. The non-fem'd seem to take a lot more stress.
Click to expand...

More solid exhaust from the north end of a southbound bull. Possibly true but even knotheads grow out lots of plants without this happening. If one thinks "regular" seed females can't or won't hermie are in for a surprise someday. Buy tested strains from known breeders and enjoy your females. I do.
 
KingIV20 said:
Just know that there's no guarantee against hermies, and they have a higher rate of hermying due to the actual process of making female seeds - but that's a technicality; no need to worry...it's usually a trait that's been bred out by the time banks will sell them...just if you make your own they have a tendency to hermie a lot.
Which strain / bank you looking at?
:leaf:
Click to expand...

I have made feminized seeds and they have been 100% female with no hermaphrodites. Are you basing this on experience or what you have read?
The bolded part has no basis in reality.


Warlock1369 said:
It's been my experience reg seeds you have a 50/50 chance of females. Add in the 50/50 chance they germ your looking at low odds. Fem seeds at least give you 80/20 germ and female plants.
Click to expand...

Properly made fem seeds have pretty much a 100% chance of being female. They can not be real hermaphrodites, but they can be stressed so that they show male flowers/pollen. A stressed female that shows both sexes is technically a hermaphrodite, but it does not contain the chromosomes from both sexes. The pollen will only produce feminized seeds. Germ rates are not affected by making feminized seeds. I have had 100% germination rates with the fem seeds I produced. I'm sure their are some duds in there though.



Opm said:
Be aware that feminized seeds can be unstable and too much stress to the plant can cause them to hermie. The non-fem'd seem to take a lot more stress.
Click to expand...


This is not true at all. Feminized seeds are basically the same as regular seeds, but they produce females.


If you take two clones from the same plant and stress one to produce pollen, then expose the other clone to the pollen, the resulting seeds will basically be clones of the mother plant in seed form.


There is a ton of misinformation about feminized seeds. I am willing to bet that it was started by people who do not know how to grow weed.
They buy fem seeds, stress the shit out of them, the plants turn male, then they bitch all over the internet about getting "hermies."


I produce fem seeds and will soon be working on crossing them.
 
Fem and regular seeds have the same likely hood to hermie it has to do with a number of factors like breeder genetics I think fems are more bang for your buck just research about the seeds you want research about the breeder make sure it's a solid genetic and you'll be laughing
 
If a plant is not stressed and shows flowers of both sexes, that is a hermaphrodite.
A feminized seed does not have male chromosomes, so it can't really be a hermaphrodite. A natural hermaphrodite will have both X and Y chromosomes. A plant that is from feminized seeds will not have the Y chromosome that produces males.
If you stress a plant that is the result of a feminized seed and it shows pollen sacks, the pollen will create feminized seeds.

If you get seeds made from a plant that naturally turns into a hermaphrodite without being stressed, the resulting seeds will be either male, female or hermaphrodite.
 
I wouldnt use anything but fem. Seed why risk getting male plant unless your planing for mothers then i would go for the other just becuse its more natral
 
Trousers said:
I have made feminized seeds and they have been 100% female with no hermaphrodites. Are you basing this on experience or what you have read?
The bolded part has no basis in reality.





Properly made fem seeds have pretty much a 100% chance of being female. They can not be real hermaphrodites, but they can be stressed so that they show male flowers/pollen. A stressed female that shows both sexes is technically a hermaphrodite, but it does not contain the chromosomes from both sexes. The pollen will only produce feminized seeds. Germ rates are not affected by making feminized seeds. I have had 100% germination rates with the fem seeds I produced. I'm sure their are some duds in there though.






This is not true at all. Feminized seeds are basically the same as regular seeds, but they produce females.


If you take two clones from the same plant and stress one to produce pollen, then expose the other clone to the pollen, the resulting seeds will basically be clones of the mother plant in seed form.


There is a ton of misinformation about feminized seeds. I am willing to bet that it was started by people who do not know how to grow weed.
They buy fem seeds, stress the shit out of them, the plants turn male, then they bitch all over the internet about getting "hermies."


I produce fem seeds and will soon be working on crossing them.
Click to expand...

Here is how this works (in really simplistic terms) Plants are bred for certain traits. To make those traits dominant parents (male and female) are selected both having that trait and bred. Their offspring are then sorted by that trait and the a male and female with the desired trait are bred together. This is done for many generations to assure that a higher and higher percentage of those offspring express that trait. After they get a stable breed with dominate traits they are looking for. they hermie the plant to get those feminized seeds. Now you grow that plant and it hermies on you because the last step of that breeding selected the hermie gene as dominant. This percentage is small but it is HIGHER than a non feminized because it hasn't been bred for that trait inadvertantly or not.

So your assumption is false.
 
hotrodharley said:
More solid exhaust from the north end of a southbound bull. Possibly true but even knotheads grow out lots of plants without this happening. If one thinks "regular" seed females can't or won't hermie are in for a surprise someday. Buy tested strains from known breeders and enjoy your females. I do.
Click to expand...

Thanks. It means a lot to me that you took the time to insult me.
 
Opm said:
Here is how this works (in really simplistic terms) Plants are bred for certain traits. To make those traits dominant parents (male and female) are selected both having that trait and bred. Their offspring are then sorted by that trait and the a male and female with the desired trait are bred together. This is done for many generations to assure that a higher and higher percentage of those offspring express that trait. After they get a stable breed with dominate traits they are looking for. they hermie the plant to get those feminized seeds. Now you grow that plant and it hermies on you because the last step of that breeding selected the hermie gene as dominant. This percentage is small but it is HIGHER than a non feminized because it hasn't been bred for that trait inadvertantly or not.

So your assumption is false.
Click to expand...

there is only one mistake in your thinking.. yes, breeders make a female plant go hermie, but they do this by the introduction of a certain chemical like collidial silver or another.. this chemical is what FORCES an otherwise healthy, hermie free plant to produce male flowers.. if they didn't introduce the chemical, the plant wouldn't go hermie.. it's not a true hermie plant, therefore there is no hermie genetics present in the plant... IT ONLY PRODUCED MALE FLOWERS BECAUSE THEY SPRAYED IT WITH CERTAIN CHEMICALS FORCING IT TO PRODUCE MALE STAMEN.. NO CHEMS, NO MALE STAMEN..
THERE IS NO HERMIE GENE TO GO ON TO THE OFFSPRING.. :D
 
racerboy71 said:
there is only one mistake in your thinking.. yes, breeders make a female plant go hermie, but they do this by the introduction of a certain chemical like collidial silver or another.. this chemical is what FORCES an otherwise healthy, hermie free plant to produce male flowers.. if they didn't introduce the chemical, the plant wouldn't go hermie.. it's not a true hermie plant, therefore there is no hermie genetics present in the plant... IT ONLY PRODUCED MALE FLOWERS BECAUSE THEY SPRAYED IT WITH CERTAIN CHEMICALS FORCING IT TO PRODUCE MALE STAMEN.. NO CHEMS, NO MALE STAMEN..
THERE IS NO HERMIE GENE TO GO ON TO THE OFFSPRING.. :D
Click to expand...

The hermie gene is recessive in EVERY plant. True the plant they sprayed wasn't carrying it as a dominate trait but the SEED it just produced just had that gene lifted in priority. If the gene wasn't there they couldn't spray it and get it to hermie because the plants would have no instructions on how to do that biological process.
 
Opm said:
The hermie gene is recessive in EVERY plant. True the plant they sprayed wasn't carrying it as a dominate trait but the SEED it just produced just had that gene lifted in priority. If the gene wasn't there they couldn't spray it and get it to hermie because the plants would have no instructions on how to do that biological process.
Click to expand...

i disagree.. there is no hermie trait, the only reason it forms male stamen is the introduction of a chemical.. i can google who it works, but it has something about the chemical halting the formation of female pistils and growing male stamens.. it's the chemical making the male bits, not genetics...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

F
Pollinating question
Replies
0
Views
283
Fishmon
F
Blue brother
BEGINNERS GROW GUIDE
Replies
2
Views
873
Blue brother
Blue brother
Thatoneguyyouknow_
Long time grower returns to the life
Replies
4
Views
1K
Thatoneguyyouknow_
Thatoneguyyouknow_
tyke1973
Advice - velvet moon greenhouse seeds doe si do x kings kush
Replies
0
Views
235
tyke1973
tyke1973
E
Need Help From Someone Who Is Familiar With Autoflowering Outdoors.
Replies
5
Views
2K
Humanrob
Humanrob
Back
Top