cannabineer
Ursus marijanus
By and large I agree. A little censorship is somewhat like being a little pregnant.The easy path has its own risks. The path that uses government censorship has to be walled off and people need to find another way. End of story. If Trump had taken office in 2016 with the ability to enforce censorship he would have shut down all ability to discuss anything he didn't approve of. It's hard to imagine the US doing worse than we did during the Covid pandemic. But Trump had the power to quash any discussion of masks or vaccines or how stupid an idea it is to rely on hydroxyquinone as a cure or even count and report how many people were dying due to Covid, it would have been worse and Trump did try to do that.
I'm suggesting tuning the civil lawsuit process as a cure because it's already there and shows it can work. It also has pitfalls and would need careful thought, testing and tuning assuming it can work at all. Maybe there are better answers. But censorship has been proven to cause more problems than it solves except for authoritarian regimes.
People are smart enough to figure out how to solve problems in spite of constraints. I think the lack of will to solve the problem of propaganda today is a larger obstacle to solving the problem than a strict interpretation of the 1A is.
“the lack of will to solve the problem of propaganda today”
where in our society do you see that lack expressed or concentrated? Would (somehow) finding a way to get the big media outlets to be less complicit in this systemic complacency be on point?
(The elephant in that room is that the GOP, and the dark-money power structure that wears it like a hat, positively cheer the propaganda machine onward.)
I’d be more at ease about it if the top dozen co-conspirators in Congress were currently facing serious lawsuits regarding their public health and election misdeeds. However my grasp of the law is poor, and I don’t know for what to effectively sue them. Someone would know if “plainly acting against the welfare of the constituents” is actionable without impeachment, which at this time could not work for political reasons.