A test in progress.... Miracle Grow soil vs. Fox Farms soil. Is MG really that bad?

Mudslide9791

Well-Known Member
Hey thanks man! Yeah I'll order some calmag for sure and I'm going to try your watering method, the outside edges crust up much faster in my 3 gallon bags like you said. Do you water the edges until you get runoff, or just moisten it?
 

GreatwhiteNorth

Global Moderator
Staff member
Damn, I should consider myself lucky, huh? I had no idea that electric was so much higher, in other places. I just took a peek at my bill, and it's $.06241 KWH. Haha, it's good to live in hillbilly country, sometimes!!!lol :wink:
$.1713 per KWH here.
 

jawbrodt

Well-Known Member
^Holy shit, you poor soul! :shock:

Hey thanks man! Yeah I'll order some calmag for sure and I'm going to try your watering method, the outside edges crust up much faster in my 3 gallon bags like you said. Do you water the edges until you get runoff, or just moisten it?
I focused on the outer edges, and it worked really well. I still let them dry out 3-4 days in between,(at about 75*) then did it. Basically, I water when the top 1-2" is dry, but because the center is still moist, I concentrate around the edges. With that much perlite added, overwatering isn't much threat, so don't panic if you think you got a bit carried away, 'cause they'll be fine. :)
 
thanks jawbrodt! your gonna be a big help. But as far as the ferts i just wasn't sure if you can leaf feed the plant with a diluted mixture of water and ferts after the first couple months. just figuring this out so i can my PUFF on!!!! lol thanks again man.
 

Jack in the Bud

Active Member
I'm going to follow this advice on my second grow and probably pick up some CalMag that Jawbrodt was talking about.

Hope yall don't mind if I tell ya a little about my grow for your advice. I don't want people thinking I'm tryin to jack a thread (seen some guys get pretty harsh on here for that) I don't have an actual grow journal up because I spent all my money on my grow and didn't have anything left to buy a camera, lol.

I started 6 Widow seedlings off under a Jumpstart T5 propagation setup. I was worried about "hot" soils for my little guys so I went to Lowes and picked up a bag of plain top soil and added some MG perlite to it. I had them in 16oz cups that were cut in half and they seemed to grow out of it in around a week. They had their roots wrapped around the sides of the 8oz little cups, so against my better judgement I think, I transplanted them into there final grow bags. 3 gallon bags with 1 part FFOF, 1 part top soil, and about 25% perlite mix. I then moved them from the little T5 (waste of money for a little 2000 lumen light I think, but I was excited and started spending money stupidly) and put them under my 400w MH. I'm on day 14 now and they just seemed to stop growing (or they are moving very slow) They are still just now producing their second set of serrated leaves (the leaves just after the first two true serrated) I'm afraid I've already screwed them up. I'm using PH adjusted water every 3-4 days (the seedlings aren't sucking up much water so the 3 gallon bags stay moist about 2-3inches under the soil according to my moisture meter) I have the light about 2 feet off the plants with a fan blowing across them (feels cool when I put my hand over them) I have them on a digital timer 18/6 but my little guys just don't seem like they are adjusting well. They look healthy though, nice and short, strong little stem in comparison to alot of lanky seedlings I see on here from folks with crappy light setups, and they are very perky and a healthy looking green, just VERY slow growth.

Am I just over analyzing the situation? I love these little guys already and I have no other seeds in case I screw up. I was planning on taking clones as I'm almost done with my separate veg room and I have a kinda crop rotation plan in mind if I can get these raised and the males culled.

I have some Jack's 20-20-20 and some Jack's Blossom Bloomer 10-30-20 but haven't begun my treatments as I wanted them to get used to the FFOF first.

You guys seem really cool and I would love some pointers. I'm hoping that I'm just being paranoid for their safety!

Thanks
mud,

I like to use the standard MG potting mix that's had 10% perlite and 10% vermiculite added to it. As far as improving drainage and keeping the soil from becoming to compacted as the grow progresses, perlite and vermiculite perform equally as well. I like getting some vermiculite in the mix because I've read (see the Wikipedia entry on it) that it aids in cation exchange. And from some of my other reading on how plants grow I know that "cation exchange" is one of the main mechanisms involved with how plants uptake various nutrients.

As far as transplanting goes.... I start seeds in 9 oz plastic cups in Jiffy Organic seed staring mix. They stay in this for around 2 weeks before I transplant them into 4"x4"x5" containers with the MG/perlite/vermiculite mix. All though I like to start in the Jiffy mix (mainly because it has a really fine particle size) it has so little Nitrogen in it that a young, strong growing plant can only go about 10 to 14 days in it before it will start yellowing from lack of nitrogen. This is kind of my indicator that it's time to upcan into the MG mix.

Additionally... while my seedlings are in the 9 oz. cups they stay close under flourescent lights on 18/6. When I upcan them into 4x4x5 pots is when I move them under the 400W MH (still on 18/6).

Then some where around day 40 to 45 I upcan them again into 1 gallon pots (again using the MG/perlite/vermiculite mix). Some where in there (while they're still in the 4x4x5 pots) I'm pinching my plants so that they grow two main colas and this sets there upward growth back a week or so. If I wasn't doing this but only growing a single main stem plant these steps would happen sooner (or they'd get to tall for my grow space). They continue to veg in the one gallon pots until around day 60 when I switch to 12/12. With in 10 to 14 days after that I've got the males and females figured out and the keeper females I'm going to grow to completion get upcanned to their final 3 gallon containers.

This may seem like a lot of unnecessary transplanting to most folks but I find some great advantages in it that make it worth the extra work to me. For one thing when their smaller (and in the smaller pots) I can keep them closer together and not have to turn on the other lights I have that I use to supplement my 400W MH (as the plants get bigger and need to be spaced farther apart). That's all about trying to keep the electrical bill down.

Next is the fact that if you keep the container it's in closer to the plants size (and it's moisture needs) you don't have as much complication with watering issues. When it's time to water you can just pour it on until it runs out the bottom and don't have to worry about the center staying to wet for to long.

And the thing I think I like the most about doing these extra transplant steps is that 3 times during a grow I get to look at my plants root system and see how it's doing.

And I don't agree with this popularly held belief that transplanting is harmful to the plant because it disturbs (or damages) it's roots. On the contrary, every time I upcan a plant I purposely try and cause minor root damage. I squeeze the root ball gently to try and loosen it up and even drag my fingernail down the sides of it in several places to try and tear some of the roots that are clustered on the surface.

I have done this to hundreds of pot plants. And if you figure in all the vegatable plants I've started from seed for the out door garden and done the same thing to, the number of plants is up way above a thousand. I am fully convinced that stressing your root ball a little bit in this fashion is way benefical in the long run. Sure, it may give the plant pause for a day or two but the gains to be had from the stronger root system this encourages translate into a healthier, stronger, higher yielding plant.

As to your plants seeming to have stalled in their growth....I agree with jawbrodt that they're just in a root building stage. A lot of people think the veg stage is all about what's growing above ground and that's what they concentrate on or judge things by. The veg stage is just as much about what's going on underground as it is with what's going on above it. Most of a plants root developement occurs in the veg stage. If you don't have a good root system before switching to 12/12 the plant will never develope one. Once a plant starts flowering it's going to put most of it's effort into that. And if you dont have a good root system to support the plants flowering efforts the yield (and the plants health) is going to suffer.

Starting out I use to veg under 24/0. I got massive amounts of foliage real quick but the plants always suffered later on in flowering and I wasn't getting very good yields. When I depotted them after harvest I could see that there just wasn't a very good, dense root system/ball. One of the great leaps forward for my growing efforts was when I switched to 18/6 for veg and started doing these multiple upcans.

Jack
 

Mudslide9791

Well-Known Member
Jack, thank you for the excellent run down of your system. I've been cutting and pasting information from you and Jawbrodt into a notepad file I have. I'm confident once I get these 6 plants to maturity that I can take 6 clones and streamline my process using techniques similar to both of yours. I've completed my veg area now so I have the ability to run a 12 plant operation. 6 in veg, 6 flowering and the cloning area if need be.

What do you guys think about 6 plants under a 400w HPS? I don't have a way to scrog, but I was thinking top and LST? Trying to keep plants 5ft or under in flower. Would I have enough light to get decent yields (not record breaking but 1.5oz dry per is what I'm kinda after. I know there is threads on this stuff but there are always so many opinions and it's hard to decipher who knows what they are talking about and who doesn't. Know what I mean?
 

Jack in the Bud

Active Member
Jack, thank you for the excellent run down of your system. I've been cutting and pasting information from you and Jawbrodt into a notepad file I have. I'm confident once I get these 6 plants to maturity that I can take 6 clones and streamline my process using techniques similar to both of yours. I've completed my veg area now so I have the ability to run a 12 plant operation. 6 in veg, 6 flowering and the cloning area if need be.

What do you guys think about 6 plants under a 400w HPS? I don't have a way to scrog, but I was thinking top and LST? Trying to keep plants 5ft or under in flower. Would I have enough light to get decent yields (not record breaking but 1.5oz dry per is what I'm kinda after. I know there is threads on this stuff but there are always so many opinions and it's hard to decipher who knows what they are talking about and who doesn't. Know what I mean?
mud,

I've never done any cloning and don't have seperate veg and flower areas so it sounds to me that jawbrodt will be the better mentor for you than my self.

I've never tried any of these other techniques like scrog, fimming, lsting, etc. either so I can't really advise about them. About 2 years ago I came across a thread on here by "Uncle Ben" about "Pinching for 2 or 4 Main Colas" and have been using that method since. If you haven't read that thread I'd recommend you give it a look.

My understanding is that HPS is the prefered light for flowering while MH is the one for vegging. All though either one will work for both and give acceptable results. I wouldn't mind having a 400W HPS fixture but even if I did I would still start my seedlings out under flourescents for the first two weeks. One good thing about HPS fixtures is that they're usually a little more energy efficent than MH.

I've got 2, 2 bulb, 4', T8 shop light fixtures (one on either side of my 400W MH) to help supplement the lightning at the edges of the space. During flowering I put a more orange/reddish spectrum bulb (similar to what HPS gives off) in them. During veg I run a bulb that gives off more of the blue/white spectrum. I've also got a 150W HPS "out door area light" fixture I turn on during flowering to help get them some more of the red/orange spectrum light (and just to get them more light in general).

Jack
 

jawbrodt

Well-Known Member
Jack, thank you for the excellent run down of your system. I've been cutting and pasting information from you and Jawbrodt into a notepad file I have. I'm confident once I get these 6 plants to maturity that I can take 6 clones and streamline my process using techniques similar to both of yours. I've completed my veg area now so I have the ability to run a 12 plant operation. 6 in veg, 6 flowering and the cloning area if need be.

What do you guys think about 6 plants under a 400w HPS? I don't have a way to scrog, but I was thinking top and LST? Trying to keep plants 5ft or under in flower. Would I have enough light to get decent yields (not record breaking but 1.5oz dry per is what I'm kinda after. I know there is threads on this stuff but there are always so many opinions and it's hard to decipher who knows what they are talking about and who doesn't. Know what I mean?

Well, 6 plants is alot to have under a 400, if they have any width to them. It pretty much means that you're going to have 3 wide, lengthwise or widthwise, and unless they are only 12" wide, you're going to exceed the light's 3' x 3' area of coverage(it's max, IMO). But, if you keep 'em narrow, and go with something similar to what jack is doing, you should be able to squeeze 'em in there. They way I grow, you'd only be able to squeeze 4 in there(2 x 2). Either way, it's all abouty filling the space, having a even canopy, and having healthy plants, if you're looking for yield. The number of plants isn't that important, as long as you use all the area of coverage. I like to go wider, because it's less work for me, as-is skipping the extra transplants, and going straight to final size, quickly. I haven't been growing that long(8-10 grows), and honestly, it took til now, that I finally got all the bugs worked out. My previous grows have been okay, but always ended up being waaaay taller than I wanted. This time, my plants are going to finish around 24" tall, and 18" wide, and should yield about 3 oz each, except for the weaker phenotypes, which I haven't sorted yet.(they should still get close to 2 ozs each) Tall plants aren't terrible, they are mostly just a pain in the ass staking, because the branches all fall over from the weight of the buds.lol They still averaged about 2 ozs each, even with deficiencies, etc....You should have no problem getting over 1 1/2 ozs each, even if you run into a few problems.

The strain has alot to do with it, as well. Since I recently made the choice to go with Ice(recommended by a very trusted grower), I'm very happy with the short, compact growth. The yield looks to be impressive, as well. I kept Crystal around, because I thought it was a great yielder, but the Ice, is going to kick it's ass, yield-wise. It looks to be yielding at least 50% more, under the same conditions. With a decent strain, you should easily be able to yield 4-6 ozs, likely more, under that 400 HPS.

I have to go to work in a couple hours, but will try to get some new pics posted. They are ready for 12/12, but I'm going to veg them a little longer. I might even keep 'em vegging for another 2 weeks, until my currents plants(in my journal) are finished. A little LST, and I'll be able to keep em short and wide. I'll be putting 4 of them under a 600 HPS, and give up perpetual growing, due to my lack of free time. I think I can pull off 4-6 ozs per plant, which won't be too bad, I think. :leaf:
 

skunky33

Active Member
My problem with Miracle Grow is not necessarily that it burns plants Fox Farms OO will do the same, but it comes with bugs. Whenever I have used MG or cheap soils they come with critters.
 

RavenMochi

Well-Known Member
My problem with Miracle Grow is not necessarily that it burns plants Fox Farms OO will do the same, but it comes with bugs. Whenever I have used MG or cheap soils they come with critters.
been covered, wherever you got them most likely left them outside, and didn't sell the quick enough...save you from digging through 50 pages... ;)
 

43Hitman

Active Member
mud,

I've never done any cloning and don't have seperate veg and flower areas so it sounds to me that jawbrodt will be the better mentor for you than my self.

I've never tried any of these other techniques like scrog, fimming, lsting, etc. either so I can't really advise about them. About 2 years ago I came across a thread on here by "Uncle Ben" about "Pinching for 2 or 4 Main Colas" and have been using that method since. If you haven't read that thread I'd recommend you give it a look.

My understanding is that HPS is the prefered light for flowering while MH is the one for vegging. All though either one will work for both and give acceptable results. I wouldn't mind having a 400W HPS fixture but even if I did I would still start my seedlings out under flourescents for the first two weeks. One good thing about HPS fixtures is that they're usually a little more energy efficent than MH.

I've got 2, 2 bulb, 4', T8 shop light fixtures (one on either side of my 400W MH) to help supplement the lightning at the edges of the space. During flowering I put a more orange/reddish spectrum bulb (similar to what HPS gives off) in them. During veg I run a bulb that gives off more of the blue/white spectrum. I've also got a 150W HPS "out door area light" fixture I turn on during flowering to help get them some more of the red/orange spectrum light (and just to get them more light in general).

Jack
Here's that thread your talking about.

https://www.rollitup.org/advanced-marijuana-cultivation/151706-uncle-bens-topping-technique-get.html
 
I just discovered this thread today, and I'm doing the exact experiment. I am going to soil for the first time after some hydro/aero problems (although my first grow yielded 21 OZ with 5 plants.) I'm using the 2 month feed organic Miracle Grow, and FFOF Organic, doing mixes of 100-0, 75-25, and 50-50 on rooted seedlings. They are now 2(?) weeks old in solo party cups. Gotta say, they all look a lot better than what Hydro has been doing for me lately... But so far 75-25 weighted towards FF looks the best at this stage, but the 50-50 mix has the most consistant, healthy looking plants. Been watering with Superthrive and Water, and Foliar fed with a really diluted solution of Flora Nova(I didn't even think when I did this, I wanted to stay all organic, oh well)

Gonna follow this as much as I can, kind of a good guide because you are only a couple weeks ahead of me... lol.


Oh also on another note, I did get 1-2 Gnats from soil, dunno which but they appeared while the humidity dome was on, so it's not from my house...
 

Auzzie07

Well-Known Member
I just discovered this thread today, and I'm doing the exact experiment. I am going to soil for the first time after some hydro/aero problems (although my first grow yielded 21 OZ with 5 plants.) I'm using the 2 month feed organic Miracle Grow, and FFOF Organic, doing mixes of 100-0, 75-25, and 50-50 on rooted seedlings. They are now 2(?) weeks old in solo party cups. Gotta say, they all look a lot better than what Hydro has been doing for me lately... But so far 75-25 weighted towards FF looks the best at this stage, but the 50-50 mix has the most consistant, healthy looking plants. Been watering with Superthrive and Water, and Foliar fed with a really diluted solution of Flora Nova(I didn't even think when I did this, I wanted to stay all organic, oh well)

Gonna follow this as much as I can, kind of a good guide because you are only a couple weeks ahead of me... lol.


Oh also on another note, I did get 1-2 Gnats from soil, dunno which but they appeared while the humidity dome was on, so it's not from my house...
That's a nice harvest. What strain was it? How long did you flower?
 
Nirvana's Bubblelicious. I pulled it just under 7 weeks. It was all guesswork being the first time but they looked perfectly ready at that time. Smooth smoke and tasted more like bubblegum the longer it was cured. Dispensaries called it world class(as i'm told), but now I can't grow anything higher that 10 inches :wall: lol.
 

stinkbudd1

Well-Known Member
This thread turned out just like i knew it would, MG kicked some premadonna ass and once again showed you do not need a chandalier to light up your kitchen a simple 75 watter will do just fine..Peace and plus rep one more time for you and the Bad ass MG......
 
Top