Whats your opinion

nongreenthumb

Well-Known Member
Today I saw a funeral car drive past on its way to a funeral, there was a policeman walking by on the pavement and he turned to the funeral car and saluted it.

Just wondering what your thoughts on this are?
 

skunkushybrid

New Member
Respect for the dead. Some catholics I know will cross themselves whenever they see a funeral procession.

I think all of us stop and think when we see something like that. People tend to go silent until it passes. It's a mark of respect.
 

mr_issues

Well-Known Member
In the US ita a law that you have to pull over and wait for the procession to pass before moving on... Or at least I was told it was a law. I always did it out of respect for the dead.
 

nongreenthumb

Well-Known Member
Respect for the dead. Some catholics I know will cross themselves whenever they see a funeral procession.

I think all of us stop and think when we see something like that. People tend to go silent until it passes. It's a mark of respect.
I agree completely though, but maybe the family inside the car would prefer if the policeman had not made any gesture at all.

What if the police hadnt performed their duty and the person in the casket died because of it, that policeman had no idea who was in the coffin so maybe it could have been seen as disrespectful to the family. I thought in todays politically correct world maybe the police wouldnt have been allowed to do that, i dont know.

What do you think?
 

heymo85

Well-Known Member
I agree completely though, but maybe the family inside the car would prefer if the policeman had not made any gesture at all.

What if the police hadnt performed their duty and the person in the casket died because of it, that policeman had no idea who was in the coffin so maybe it could have been seen as disrespectful to the family. I thought in todays politically correct world maybe the police wouldnt have been allowed to do that, i dont know.

What do you think?
yea i think exactly like you...to be respectful is one thing but saluting?i dunno.
 

skunkushybrid

New Member
I see where you are coming from, but surely the family will only be thinking of their son. Also, any intelligent person knows that you can't blame a whole group for the actions of one member.

if it were the officer in question, then I could understand there being a problem.
 

7xstall

Well-Known Member
while in uniform you are expected to be very "proper" when you address other people, i was taught that even way back in cub scouts.

so, it's natural to salute as a gesture of respect. it's painfully difficult to imagine someone being able to find offense in that act.
 

Jordy Villain

Well-Known Member
i personally might give a nod but hey I wasn't saluting the guy when he was alive so w/e.

"they bring you flowers when you dead but no soup when you're sick."
 

odinzu

Active Member
Yea, its a salute to respect. I do the same when something like that happens. I just don't salute, I am quiet and respect the person passing by.
 

nongreenthumb

Well-Known Member
Yeah we all have a level of respect, and I think that stopping what your doing and bowing your head as they pass is probably more respectful as a gesture goes, I could have understood it better maybe if the policeman had done this, it just seemed like a strange gesture to me at the time and I wanted to get other peoples opinions on it.

In todays politically correct world, larger groups of people are penalised for the minorities so as not to offend anyone. I just found it strange in this instance that a policeman although showing his respect was allowed to do so in this manor. I thought that in some instances this geture wouldnt be respectful to the family, so then It got me thinking about what they are told they can and cant do on this subject, they must have guidelines for it.
 

battosai

Well-Known Member
Yeah we all have a level of respect, and I think that stopping what your doing and bowing your head as they pass is probably more respectful as a gesture goes, I could have understood it better maybe if the policeman had done this, it just seemed like a strange gesture to me at the time and I wanted to get other peoples opinions on it.

In todays politically correct world, larger groups of people are penalised for the minorities so as not to offend anyone. I just found it strange in this instance that a policeman although showing his respect was allowed to do so in this manor. I thought that in some instances this geture wouldnt be respectful to the family, so then It got me thinking about what they are told they can and cant do on this subject, they must have guidelines for it.
maybe the cop knew the deceased. maybe it was someone of the military and he was acknowledging that. funerals always feel like church
 

Jordy Villain

Well-Known Member
if it were a cop there'd be 10 million cop cars following the procession. same thing if it was military.. there'd be horses and shit and 30 full sized flags lol. that cop was just kindof a tool, I've decided.
 
Top