Greatest Player in NFL History?

dr2brains

Well-Known Member
No you're not.
Can you honestly say that Farve is even the best QB ever?

And we have gave very valid points...you seemed to be blinded by the number 4.
 

growbuddy1

Active Member
He throws the ball hard is that what makes the greatest NFL player ever? He's called a gunslinger for a reason.
Uhm, no that's not what I said, you must have trouble reading as well as creating your own opinion. It's that paired with the 50,000 other things I've mention that make him one of the greatest athletes.

I never said Walter Payton sucks, he was a great player too, but to say Brett Favre isn't one of the best players to play the game clearly means you have no respect for the sport or just really don't understand the game.

Either way I'm not gonna argue, you guys will continue to suck ESPN's tit for all your info.
 

growbuddy1

Active Member
Can you honestly say that Farve is even the best QB ever?
There is no such thing as best anymore, they are to many different styles of play that offer different pro's / con's

There is in fact a group of elite athletes that not only excelled at their position, but were good teammate and everything else that goes along with the sport. Not just what happens on Sunday. It's about what happens at practice, off the field, what you say to the press, when you're not in the game, that matter just as much as what you do on the field.

To say Brett Favre isn't part of that elite group just means you don't know shit about football. He was a coach, a mentor, a leader, and a player all at the same time his entire career, with out missing a single game.


SunBiz1 and dr2brains - you guys should go 69 since your both so into dick sucking. You could even role play and wear different jersey's. Sunbiz1 can wear a tom brady jersey, and dr2brains can wear a hasselback jersey to start. Have fun! Let the real men talk about sports now ;)
 

Sunbiz1

Well-Known Member
Hell yeah he would! I grew up in a Steeler household and he is legend. This man would break fingers tape them on the sideline and be in the next play! This man was a beast!
Players from the 70's Steelers rate the same as Lombardi's Packers a decade earlier in some respects...like the 85' Bears...too many good players to single out.

Mike Webster was the best player in Pittsburgh during that era...he made the O work IMHO.
 

dr2brains

Well-Known Member
If I'm not mistaken the threads topic is "Greatest Player In NFL History" and that's not Farve.
Farve was definitely a good quality QB and has a good charisma but his name has no place in a thread of "Greatest Player In NFL History"

I never said Farve sucks.
 

dr2brains

Well-Known Member
You've yet to show ONE valid point. You guys just keep talking about sucking dicks...
Like I mentioned before, what running back had more receiving yards? What player who wasn't quarterback threw for more yards?
Are these not valid points?
 

growbuddy1

Active Member
but his name has no place in a thread of "Greatest Player In NFL History"
Are you kidding me? You two obviously don't know shit about football.



LEAGUE STATS

Career Completions
1) Brett Favre 5,021

Career Passing Yards
1) Dan Marino 61,361
2) Brett Favre 57,500

Career Touchdown Passes
1) Dan Marino 420
2) Brett Favre 414

Career Wins as a Starting QB
1) John Elway 148
2) Dan Marino 147
3) Brett Favre 147

Consecutive Games Started
1) Jim Marshall 270
2) Mick Tingelhoff 240
3) Brett Favre 237



GREEN BAY PACKERS TEAM RECORDS

Career Games Played
1) Brett Favre 239
2) Bart Starr 196

Career Passing Yards
1) Brett Favre 57,500
2) Bart Starr 24,718

Career Passing Yards
1) Brett Favre 57,500
2) Bart Starr 24,718

Career Completions
1) Brett Favre 5,021
2) Bart Starr 1,808

Career Touchdown Passes
1) Brett Favre 414
2) Bart Starr 152



How does he manage all that charisma? With being top 3 for ALL those stats in the league, with out being considered for "your" greatest player in nfl history. So in comparison, YES he is the best Packer QB as of now, and YES he was one of the best QB's the league has ever seen, stats wise, and character wise.

Gimme a break, you guys don't know shit about football or what it takes to compete like that.
 

growbuddy1

Active Member
Like I mentioned before, what running back had more receiving yards? What player who wasn't quarterback threw for more yards?
Are these not valid points?
I could say the same thing about Brett Favre having more rushing TD's than other QB's - and more rushing yards than most QB's

That's also the position, QB's don't get that opportunity. All that means to me is Payton was a complete back. It's not unheard of... Backs are supposed to catch short passes, they're supposed to block. All Payton did was his job as a RB, he did it very well obviously.. but to compare those two players is like apples to oranges.
 

Sunbiz1

Well-Known Member
I could say the same thing about Brett Favre having more rushing TD's than other QB's - and more rushing yards than most QB's

That's also the position, QB's don't get that opportunity. All that means to me is Payton was a complete back. It's not unheard of... Backs are supposed to catch short passes, they're supposed to block. All Payton did was his job as a RB, he did it very well obviously.. but to compare those two players is like apples to oranges.
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3088/2743581613_4773d18e34_o.jpg

You and Brett seem to have much in common...lol
 

dr2brains

Well-Known Member
Are you kidding me? You two obviously don't know shit about football.



LEAGUE STATS

Career Completions
1) Brett Favre 5,021

Career Passing Yards
1) Dan Marino 61,361
2) Brett Favre 57,500

Career Touchdown Passes
1) Dan Marino 420
2) Brett Favre 414

Career Wins as a Starting QB
1) John Elway 148
2) Dan Marino 147
3) Brett Favre 147

Consecutive Games Started
1) Jim Marshall 270
2) Mick Tingelhoff 240
3) Brett Favre 237



GREEN BAY PACKERS TEAM RECORDS

Career Games Played
1) Brett Favre 239
2) Bart Starr 196

Career Passing Yards
1) Brett Favre 57,500
2) Bart Starr 24,718

Career Passing Yards
1) Brett Favre 57,500
2) Bart Starr 24,718

Career Completions
1) Brett Favre 5,021
2) Bart Starr 1,808

Career Touchdown Passes
1) Brett Favre 414
2) Bart Starr 152



How does he manage all that charisma? With being top 3 for ALL those stats in the league, with out being considered for "your" greatest player in nfl history. So in comparison, YES he is the best Packer QB as of now, and YES he was one of the best QB's the league has ever seen, stats wise, and character wise.

Gimme a break, you guys don't know shit about football or what it takes to compete like that.
According to your stats Dan Marino is a better QB.
 

growbuddy1

Active Member
According to your stats Dan Marino is a better QB.
Those are the current RECORDS. It's like you guys are clawing at anything you can to say Brett isn't one of the best. You've lost this argument brutally. Yes Marino has some better stats, but he wasn't the complete player Favre was. I'm moving on, it's like argueing with a half retarded 5 year old.

The fact that he is top 5 for almost all the QB stats, on top of his character, easily puts him in that elite club.
 

Sunbiz1

Well-Known Member
Wow what a surprise, more gay comments from Sunbiz..

Go live out your bi-curious fantasy already so you can stop living in denial and taking it out on random people online. Come out of the closet dude, no one will hate you for it, hopefully your parents except your new lifestyle![/QUOT

You're not even a fun troll...bye.
 
Top