SOIL vs HYDRO

Status
Not open for further replies.
I say these plants look good but how old are they?6 months a year they sure arnt on a 60 day grow,ont thing i noticed in these pics that i like and thats the cfls under the plant good idea
 

Japanfreak

New Member
you say its easy to follow the chart??? how bout this a monkey could plant a plant in soil and put it under a light and water every now and then... if you get a raw ass soil/soil mix you shouldnt even need to add any nutes....
Sure but the monkey will probably fuck it up but because some e^parrot told him the wrong soil to buy, the monkey would then come on to RIU asks what up and be told to flush.
 

Japanfreak

New Member
hydro can be cool sure and your ph is sound i just prefer soil,but tell me this,what do you think about 2lbs per light with soil that is 3 yrs old,can you do that with hydro,how about this 18 foot tall plants producing 8 lbs per plant with stalks 9 inches in diamiter,wheres your hydro in this mix,marijuana is a plant that grows in soil and soil is the best medium in my oppinion,and no matter what you have heard or what you might think a lot can go wrong with a hydro set up,as far as the grade goes,the best weed ive ever smoked was grown outdoors in cali by an 70 yr old grower.If you want to grow soil then it all comes down to your soil composition,make sure you have both macro and micro nuets in there proper proportion,make sure the soil aireation is good,be sure that you follow the instuctions on your nuets,you can correct under feeding by giving the plant more nuets,over feeding requires more measures,last but not least keep your ph between 6.2 and 7.If you do this you will grow really dank bud.Ask your self this;of all the cannibis cup winners how many where soil and how many where hydro.try about 95% soil winners.That should tell you somthing right there.
It doesn't tell me much because I actually know what's what and I don't look at one cycle and go "Wow" I look at weights and cycles over years and indoors a good hydro grower can grow a lot more than a good soil grower. But if I was a collector of stems and shit I would be really really impressed.

Cannabis Cup? That's the event for kids in Holland right? The fixed event that is paid with bribes and is laughed at all over the world right? Give me a fucking break, cannabis cup.
 

Japanfreak

New Member
Because many people scorch their plants with nutes.
That's one reason, brought that up somewhere in this mess, that a lot of soil growers kill their soil and dump in hydro nutes anyway. That's why blanket statements like "soil is more forgiving" are just bullshit. People can fuck up anything, even falling down.
 

YepYep

Active Member
idk..if i let the plants get to be the size that it would take to put out that kind of yeild ...maybe. I wonder in those grow cups what the soil to hydro ratio is.
 
japanfreak huh.ive seen a lot of your post man all you really do is rip on people every one is an etard or parrott but you huh,maybe if you grew good pot and smoked it it would mellow you out,here in the states there are several dozen cannibis cups,it just so happens holland has one too,if your bud was good eneough you might have a chance but with all your negitive energy i cant see your bud being very good and i doubt very seriously that you are putting up numbers like i posted,hydro cant compete with soil,smoke your hydro watch it snap crackle and pop for you,oh yah at least soil grown weed smells and taist like weed and not a chemy solution.When it comes down to it the stats out weigh your etard eparrott rant and the proof is in the customer satisfaction,the people have voted and the vote is for soil grown cannibis.
 

Stoner.Barbie

Well-Known Member
soil is more forgiving.. if your power goes out your not fucked with soil has you are with most hydro setups... especially dwc! if you fuck something up in your rez. that will fuck up all your plants... much more work with hydro monitering ph, ppm ect. while soil is laboring in that you have to spend extra time watering one by one... but i dont mind that at all.. i love this shit...

ive never had any issue in soil
hear hear well said (or ist here, here?) hahahahaaa sorry, been eating special christmas cookies.
 

MrStickyScissors

Well-Known Member
japanfreak huh.ive seen a lot of your post man all you really do is rip on people every one is an etard or parrott but you huh,maybe if you grew good pot and smoked it it would mellow you out,here in the states there are several dozen cannibis cups,it just so happens holland has one too,if your bud was good eneough you might have a chance but with all your negitive energy i cant see your bud being very good and i doubt very seriously that you are putting up numbers like i posted,hydro cant compete with soil,smoke your hydro watch it snap crackle and pop for you,oh yah at least soil grown weed smells and taist like weed and not a chemy solution.When it comes down to it the stats out weigh your etard eparrott rant and the proof is in the customer satisfaction,the people have voted and the vote is for soil grown cannibis.
:joint::joint::hump::hump::joint::joint:
 

brick20

Well-Known Member
on a big perpetual level soil just isnt practical, and if your power goes out your fucked with soil and hydro but how often does power go out...
 
look 2lbs a light 10 lights 3 yr old soil tripple a grade dank buds every 6-8 weeks whats up with that its perpetual and fruitful cost about 1500 hundo a grow with nuets and electric and thats cali elec prices high as hell other states knock this down to 700 a grow cuz there elec is cheaper.and where do you get your fucked with soil if your power goes out?If the power is out for 3 days at worst all you have to do is throw a couple big flash lights in the room and it will keep them from flowering,with a hydro set up you better have a couple good generators or your not gonna have any plants left man soil beats out hydro on every level taist quality, its organic for real,and yah a lot of people quote"its more forgiving",well duh thats because it is,but either way if you really want to grow tripple a dank buds you need to be a mad scientist,learn everything you can from strain manipulation to what amino acids the plant requires,becuz if you dont know then you dont know,i got 20 yrs exp in both hydro and soil and if hydro was a better and cheaper way to grow the best bud possible i would be doing it,and so would everyone else ,at least its better than led lights
 

brick20

Well-Known Member
so if u live in a well populated area such as an apartment and u keep bringing in and out big bags of soil, that should rise suspicion
 

MrStickyScissors

Well-Known Member
DSCN0274.JPGDSCN0271.JPGDSCN0265.JPGDSCN0270.JPGDSCN0269.JPGDSCN0139.JPGDSCN0140.JPGMMS_Resized_Pix(30).jpegDSCN0263.JPGI run 8 one thousands and 3 four hundreads for veg and my bill is 750 a month. i live in cali. only pulling a little over or a little under a pound a light with 7 plants per light.alloceansforest soil
 

Lord Dangly Bits

Well-Known Member
OK, What the Hell is up With JapanFreak? Is he trying to boost the number of his post? He Puts out about 5 post in 7 minutes.

And I think you All are wrong. You over water in Soil and it is a Bitch. Your Pumps shut down in Hydro and OH FUDGE! SOIL SUCKS!! HYDRO SUCKS!!
With Flood and drain you are wasting a ton of money on Nutrients you will dump. In Soil if you screw up your soil mix you have trouble turning it around. Bat Guano and such is not always the same. With Areo you can have tubes and such plug, so on and so on.

NOW WITH CANNA COCO. This is THE SHEET!!. IMPOSSIBLE to over water. You get ALL THE BENEFITS Of taste and smell of soil with out the trouble. It even looks like Soil. And do not buy those stupid low quality BAILS. It is PH neutral. If you over Nut it, just give it a good watering with 50% run off of PH water and wallah, all good. I truly can not understand why more people are not using this stuff. When you are finished with your grow, you just pull up the roots, throw it in 5 gallon buckets with holes in the bottom and flush it with a mix of Cannazyme or one of the other product. Let it sit for a few days. then flush it with PH'd water and use it again and again. I have used it up to 5 times, with no ill effect. I can grow trees in this stuff or keep them nice and small.

But here is the thing!!! To each his own. If we all acted the same. Liked the same things. Looked the same. Screwed the same. This would be one boring WORLD! If you like soil, then use soil. If you like Hydro, then grow in Hydro. Myself, I have done most of the techniques, and I am sticking with Coco in grow bags with a simple drip system. But this does not mean I will not still experiment with new techniques, new supplies and such. And might someday change my ways. But at this time, Coco is the easiest, most productive way I have found my myself.

I have seen this same argument more then just a couple of times over the years on this site. It always ends up the same way. Kind of like, you got Peanut Butter in my Chocolate!! NO!!! you got Chocolate in My Peanut Butter!!

Peace to all, Merry Christmas and have a Happy New year, and GROW ON!!
 
ok this is a nice set however think of this instead of pots how about raised beds and instead of growing 56 plants grow 130,your lights are more than eneough to grow 180 plants yes you will have to spend more on nuets but your yield will be arround 2 lbs a light,as it is you have more light than plants,that my friend is waisting money.
 

MrStickyScissors

Well-Known Member
ok this is a nice set however think of this instead of pots how about raised beds and instead of growing 56 plants grow 130,your lights are more than eneough to grow 180 plants yes you will have to spend more on nuets but your yield will be arround 2 lbs a light,as it is you have more light than plants,that my friend is waisting money.

I pull more weight off less plants per light when they all get gud light. I see what your saying though. as many plants as you can put under a light that will grow correctly is best cause you have to pay for the electricity. I have allways wanted to grow 20 plants in 2 gallon pots and try and pull a zip a plant.
 
one more piece of info about soil;microbes.soil contains micro organisms that basically eat it,these microbes produce byproducts that are benificial to the uptake and obsorbsion of amino acids by the plant.they are only found in soiland im sorry to say but these microbes make the difference and they are basically what makes soil better than hydro,but as the dangly man said to each there own
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top