I actually took your silence on the matter to mean that you weren't trying to take credit for it. I thought silence was actually a very good response considering I attacked pretty hard at that one. You didn't defend your creation of the odor bucket so I dropped it and figured we could all go one. I was genuinely confused when I saw this today and thought "maybe he does think he invented this thing?" So I was asking genuinely if you believed that. It's just that when you capitalize things such as Roseman's Odor Bucket it sorta implies you invented the idea. I should have worded my original challenge to the credit of this idea in a less confrontational matter, I just had a lot of respect for videoman and he helped me out a lot when I was a newb. I left this forum for some time and when I returned, he was gone and I haven't seen a post in a long time, makes me wonder.