How Plants Respond to Music.

Discussion in 'Newbie Central' started by smartguy345, Dec 11, 2009.

  1.  
    smartguy345

    smartguy345 New Member

    So i did a breif research on RIU on this and nothing came up. Be nice to know if anyone did any side test comparison. I always wondered if music in the grow room would help these ladies thrive? Not only that but help creat background noise to cover any humming sound any equipment may generate.

    Anyone care to input on this method? I am planing on picking up a portable radio and set it to a classical station.

    Here is some info I gathered from the INTERNET:

    Plants Respond to Music

    [FONT=Arial, Sans-Serif][FONT=Verdana, Sans-Serif]Did you know that your plants respond to music the same as human beings do?[/FONT][/FONT] [FONT=Arial, Sans-Serif][FONT=Verdana, Sans-Serif]It has been proven scientifically through many experiments that plants thrive on music, though there are some who do not agree with the theory. Gardeners, however, have no doubt that fading flowers get a new lease of life by music and flowers blossom in their fullest glory listening to music. In 1973, Dorothy Retallack's book The Sound of Music and Plants based on scientific experiments created ripples.[/FONT][/FONT]

    Retallack began her experiment at the Colorado Women's College in Denver. Using three separate laboratories containing the same species of plants, Retallack began her experiment. Piping in different types of music to each facility, she recorded the daily growth of each plant. The results were quite surprising. The plants in the laboratory where music was played daily for three hours a day grew twice as large and became twice as healthy as those in a music-free environment. On the other extreme, plants in the laboratory where music was played for eight hours a day died within two weeks of the start of the experiment.

    Dorothy Retallack tried experimenting with different types of music. She played rock to one group of plants and, soothing music to another. The group that heard rock turned out to be sickly and small whereas the other group grew
    [FONT=Arial, Sans-Serif][FONT=Verdana, Sans-Serif]large and healthy. What's more surprising is that the group of plants listening to the soothing music grew bending towards the radio just as they bend towards the sunlight.

    This experiment encouraged many individuals and organizations to exercise the act of playing music to plants. These connoisseurs of music warn you about the sort of music that you play. The plants will grow better if you play soft soothing music of old era instead of loud rock music of Gen X.
    [/FONT][/FONT]
    [FONT=Arial, Sans-Serif][FONT=Verdana, Sans-Serif]The noisy rock music will only make the plants grow feeble and sick. Preferably, play Mozart, Bach, or Beethoven to make your plant grow better. Another important point that we can pick up from Retallack's experiments is the duration of music. If you are keen on playing music to your plants, keep the time limit to be about three hour. This will make the plants grow healthy and properly. An overdose of music can seriously destroy the plants.

    Although music is not an absolutely proven factor in plant development, several studies, along with Dorothy Retallack's groundbreaking series of experiments, have aided the musical development theory. If you are interested in exploring this option with your own garden, consult The Sound of Music and Plants or other resources to ensure you expose your plants to the optimal type of music for the
    [/FONT][/FONT]
    [FONT=Arial, Sans-Serif][FONT=Verdana, Sans-Serif]appropriate amount of time.[/FONT][/FONT]



  2.  
    Andreyy

    Andreyy Active Member


    I remember the Mythbusters experiment that showed plants grow better when you talk to them, regardless of what you say to them though, and as for music, Rock is the way to go :bigjoint:

    And btw, the plants that got cussed at and insulted grew better than the ones on classical music IIRC :razz:


    Apparently, the conclusions collide.

    By my recollection, Mythbusters grew peas in a greenhouse, with music\speech delivered via a stereo, that i think was always on, but i`m not 100% of it. Apparently, this chick did an indoor grow
  3.  
    smartguy345

    smartguy345 New Member

    Good to get more input on this.. I was thinking keeping the radio on 24/7 but there saying it kill the plants.. oh decisons decisons.. I dont even know if its possible to keep my radio on a timer.
  4.  
    Illegal Smile

    Illegal Smile Guest

    I don't think there is any good evidence for either but I'm more inclined to think human talking might make a difference over a radio. Likewise, I doubt that eitherone can do any harm. Growing is full of superstitions.
  5.  
    Phreak8987

    Phreak8987 Member

    OK. Heres how this music stuff works my friend. From what ive heard as far as music goes, Classical and Rock music work the best. Also, the perfect number for music and plants is 3. Play more than 3 hours and your plant may react negativelely. But i myself play 3 hours of Phish for my plants and they seem to be loving it...(until this one time my buddy accidentally put Kanye in my player and killed my plants)
  6.  
    simpsonsampson420

    simpsonsampson420 Well-Known Member

    i would think that humans talking would be more beneficial due to the co2 we breath out.. thats what plants breath in.. makes sense we would boost them talking to them.. although i dont know if the little bit of talking and co2 boost that they would get from us would be that beneficial to make a difference...

    i really just think the sound waves stimulate the plants more than anything.. not the sounds itself... im sure you could play a recording of loony tunes and get the same results as actual music.. its the stimulation that does the work from the sound waves...

    imagine its like this.. if you take an animal.. put it in a cage.. feed it.. water it... let it out.. but NEVER give it any other stimulation than that you'll have one weak animal.. even if it isnt weak weak, it will still not be as strong as it would have been had it got stimulation from people and other animals.. if that makes sense..

    i think the same holds true for any "live" thing.. without some sort of stimulation things never grow to their fullest.. outside plants have all kind of audio stimulants that produce sound waves they absorb (since plants cant actually hear like we do).. indoors tho its not always true.. they are stuck in rooms where typically the only noise is the hum of fans and such.. it would make sense in some round about way that the music would act as a some sort of stimuli and the plant would grow more from it...

    now whether the is scientifically true or can be proven is what im not sure of..

    yes, the mythbusters did it and proved it on their show.. but unless all the plants they grew were from clones then its not really a fair comparison since their genetics would have been different.. think about when you grow 2 of the same strains and they grow differently.. unless they are from the same mother and contain the same phenos then its somewhat a false answer they got...
  7.  
    naked gardener

    naked gardener Active Member

    I read that same article (and a few more on the same topic) a few years ago and was totally inspired to play a few hours of music daily in my garden. I mostly played sonatas by bach and Perpetual Motion by Bela Fleck--tho i didn't do a side by side comparison--they seemed to really thrive.

    From what I understand, the roots (which are extremely sensitive) feel the vibrations----and supposedly that is how plants and trees essentially "communicate" w one another in nature. I believe it. The music had an extremely positive effect on me as well--which I'm sure also "vibed" to my girls--so yeah--you can't go wrong w GOOD COMPLEX and POSITIVE music (positive not in the lyrics necessarily--but in the feelings or vibes it will evoke from it's audience.)

    I'm glad to see someone wote about this
  8.  
    naked gardener

    naked gardener Active Member

    I also believe what simsponsampson420 said about the CO2--we do omit quite a bit when we breathe out--but even more when we talk and EVEN MORE THAN THAT when we sing--so, next time you are in your garden (presumably naked :lol:), SING. Your fucking lungs out.

    they'll be your biggest fans
  9.  
    Lobotomist

    Lobotomist Well-Known Member

    I wonder if it's the wavelength of the music that helps it. Plants gather E and photosynthesize using the visual spectrum of waves, but go at an even lower wavelength and you get the audible spectrum, we use different wavelengths in the visual spectrum for different stages of growth. I wonder if different music, producing different wavelengths, in different stages of growth would be better than others. More research needs to be done on this for sure.
  10.  
    smartguy345

    smartguy345 New Member

    SO how did people get the music on a timer? I would imagine a radio would need to be pressed on, after the timer turns the radio on, right? Nice to get more input.. looks like there is mixed reviews, but I wouldnt mind trying this out.
  11.  
    ganjaluvr

    ganjaluvr Well-Known Member

    hey, just wanted to throw in that I am currently doing an experiment just like this.


    I have one 'Lemon Skunk' (was a feminized seed.. that's all i order.. is feminized seeds) growing.. she's actually just about to end her second week of flowering.. and start the third week of flowering.


    I have one speaker (surround sound system) that I have placed inside my grow box.. and I set the speaker right next to the plant. I've been conducting this experiment for a while now.. and I have found (believe it or not) that certain types of music.. actually can and does influence at what speed your plant will grow.

    Now, as for the music making your plant grow BUSHIER?!?! I... I don't know about that for sure.. as I didn't really see any difference in that aspect of the experiment.

    However, I can say that 'Classical Music' 'Jazz music' and believe it or not.. even soft 'Rock `N` Roll' music... did in fact seem to add height to the plant that had music next to it.. as compared to the plant that had no speaker inside it's growbox.

    Those three types of music seemed to actually influence the plant.. to grow more quickly.
    ***I know.. this shit sounds like a myth.. but hey.. even Mythbusters proved that this is a plausible experiment.***

    I didn't see any advantages from giving the plant music therapy.. other than like I said.. it did seem to make the plant grow more quickly.. and even seemed to be a little more healthy.


    I know that there are some people reading this thread.. and telling themselves.. ahh this is just a bunch of bullshit. Well, all I can say to those people thinking that... is to tell you to try the experiment for yourself if you would like to do so. And see for yourself.. that it does work.


    The trick is to actually place the speaker.. or point the speaker down towards the plant's medium (my case.. it was soil).

    Why? Well, because the roots are what actually respond to the vibrations that the speaker emits.. while music is being played through it. It's the different sound waves.. which.. in return produce different length of sound waves.. which in return.. the roots do actually respond to... hence the reason why I only saw a difference with the three types of music listed earlier which were the following: 'Classical'; 'Rock `N` Roll'; and 'Jazz' music.

    The one that seemed to have the most influence.. was actually Jazz. With second in line.. being Classical... and thirdly in line.. 'Rock N Roll'.


    If anyone else has tried this experiment and had different results.. or almost the same results.. feel free to message me.

    I'm interested in talking with other people who have also tried this experiment.. to see maybe if we can try and combine our information that we collected from our experiments.. to maybe try and perfect this method. :)

    Thanks for reading. Have a great weekend.

    Peace.
  12.  
    Delux83

    Delux83 Well-Known Member

    ok ok im gonna give it a shot these should be ready in about 3 weeks then i think ill play some bob marley cant stand classical
  13.  
    shylas

    shylas Active Member

    I have a sirius radio plugged in with my timer in my veg room.
    It is tuned to ch 79 a classical station.
    I would compare this with the dif that using molasses makes
    during flower. It's a clear dif.. Just with the general look of health.
    Scientists have done numerous studies
    on the best music to play to plants & the best genres were new age type
    wiccan earth music & classical because the sounds closely mimic nature for
    plants that are not in natural habitat,( that's one theory on genre) and furthermore that plants like sounds in general.
    They do not like complete silence
    There is currently no study I'm aware of about the benefits of playing outdoor plants music.

    I will continue to play my plants new age & classical & I firmly believe in the results.

Share This Page