Home built system, or manufactured system from a hydroponics company?

Umlah000

Member
Home built system, or manufactured system from a hydroponics company?


Hi all -

I've been looking at various examples of home built hydro systems, some of which were nicely done . . . but this does present a question.

Recently I was at the local Home Depot, walking around with my list of materials and trying to get a handle on what it would actually cost, and also the construction time, trial & error testing, and all that to build a home made hydroponics system.

Then I took a second look at some of the pre-manufactured hydro systems from various manufacturers, like Botanicare, General Hydroponics, and several others.

Though these various systems look pricey at first glance, the reality is that by the time I added up all the various components and materials that I would have to get from the hardware store, and figured in the time to construct and test my home made system, perhaps the pre-manufactured hydro systems are not that pricey after all.

There's actually more to this than what first meets the eye.

Also, the manufacturers have already been through their own trial & error testing, developing new prototypes and refining these designs, as they have been used by an expanding user base.


This sort of reminds me of PC computers, especially from a previous time, when a lot of people (myself included) would buy various components, and then build their own custom computer.

In today's world, unless you're going for something really esoteric or high end, it makes sense just to buy the computer as a fully manufactured, ready to go product.

From what I've seen in various catalogs and at trade shows, I think the same can be said for current hydroponics systems. The technology has definitely become much more sophisticated, and various designs have been "field tested" for years.

I don't want to re-invent the wheel . . . I just want to set it up, plug it in, and follow the instructions. If anything does go wrong with a manufactured system, at least I can call up tech support for the products being used.


Of course, if anyone out there thinks I might be wrong about this, or just has an opinion to share, I'd appreciate any thoughts offered.

Ciao . . .
 

Give Me

Member
Home built system, or manufactured system from a hydroponics company?


Hi all -

I've been looking at various examples of home built hydro systems, some of which were nicely done . . . but this does present a question.

Recently I was at the local Home Depot, walking around with my list of materials and trying to get a handle on what it would actually cost, and also the construction time, trial & error testing, and all that to build a home made hydroponics system.

Then I took a second look at some of the pre-manufactured hydro systems from various manufacturers, like Botanicare, General Hydroponics, and several others.

Though these various systems look pricey at first glance, the reality is that by the time I added up all the various components and materials that I would have to get from the hardware store, and figured in the time to construct and test my home made system, perhaps the pre-manufactured hydro systems are not that pricey after all.

There's actually more to this than what first meets the eye.

Also, the manufacturers have already been through their own trial & error testing, developing new prototypes and refining these designs, as they have been used by an expanding user base.


This sort of reminds me of PC computers, especially from a previous time, when a lot of people (myself included) would buy various components, and then build their own custom computer.

In today's world, unless you're going for something really esoteric or high end, it makes sense just to buy the computer as a fully manufactured, ready to go product.

From what I've seen in various catalogs and at trade shows, I think the same can be said for current hydroponics systems. The technology has definitely become much more sophisticated, and various designs have been "field tested" for years.

I don't want to re-invent the wheel . . . I just want to set it up, plug it in, and follow the instructions. If anything does go wrong with a manufactured system, at least I can call up tech support for the products being used.


Of course, if anyone out there thinks I might be wrong about this, or just has an opinion to share, I'd appreciate any thoughts offered.

Ciao . . .
Um Welcome,
I totally agree with you, I have been doing the same thing. I think its like most things They can sell cheaper because they buy more materials cheaper. I found for example Larger diameter PVC is a bit pricey well at least the fittings were. I am looking at it like I am going to let someone else that has time/money figure it out and go from there :) I think it boils down to can you do it yourself? I have friends that could mow their own lawn but would rather pay me :) I also know that for me cost/budget is a factor so if I can build that $1500 rig downsized a bit for $250 why not? I think for some it is a sense of knowing I did that :) Do you have any specific plans or ideas? If you post specs folks might be able to offer suggestions as to how to best utilize your space :) Happy Growing 2 All
 

donutpunched

Active Member
I built my own UC system.... Though I saved some... Not much money.... The amount of time, planning and changes I had to make made me make a promise to myself that I would buy one already made.....
 

Xcon

Active Member
I built a flood and drain for about $150

You can use anything for your flood table, my tub cost $12.
425gph water pump $45
large air pump w/ 4 outputs $22
50L bag of hydroton $35
GH series nutes $35
fittings/tubing $10-$15
bottle of cal-max $20
rubbermaid tote for a res

There are good reasons to keep your hydro setup as simple as possible, the less fittings you have, the less chance of a leak and it keeps costs down. A simple setup has the same potential as a complicated one... deliver nutes, water, and oxygen to the roots in the proper ratio.

Also, those kits don't usually come with a combo meter or an r/o system, so if you want to do hydro right it'll cost you another $200-$300 on top of the cost for the hydro kit. If you think about it, the money you save building your own will pay for both of those items.
 

ATL HYDRO

Active Member
I bought an 18 gallon dwc hydro system on ebay, from a seller called billyponics. It was $120 including shipping, he sends you the reservoir, with 4 netpots, rockwool, hydroton, drip emitters, a water pump, an air pump and airstone, spray bottle, a detailed instruction book and even a bottle of GROW from general hydroponics. great deal, you could barely build a system and buy all those components for that much. It is everything you need except a seed/clone and a light. http://www.ebay.com/itm/Hydroponic-Grow-System-DWC-Drip-Combo-Complete-setup-/160565454171?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&var=&hash=item6b1b59bfca

plus the guy is very newbie friendly and promises grow tip for life.
 
Top