Anything you put between the light and the plant will decrease the lumens. Tempered glass is MUCH better than plexiglass; acrylic will deform, as bigv said. It might be fine during the winter but during the summer, you'll be really glad you have the tempered glass. You can probably get a piece locally from a glass shop. I've found that the pieces that come with the reflectors are barely big enough to work; in fact, I used silicone to permanently seal mine into place after my last grow. I can change the bulb through the 6" holes and now I don't have to worry about the glass falling out.