Are these still good...

JSB99

Well-Known Member
I was wondering if these powder nutes are still good. They are from 8 years ago, when I was growing via rdwc. The grow salts are still really powdery, and the flower salts are a little stiff, but not like a rock. They've been in my attic since 8 years ago.

 

OldMedUser

Well-Known Member
Those nutes are just salts like the pink Himalayan sea salt I use on my food and it's millions of years old so I'd say use 'em up.

I bought gallon jugs of AN 3-part in 2002 and still have some left that I used last year when I ran out. The plants didn't seem to mind. Got all new jugs last year.

In Kelowna this week I had to order a 500ml jug of Bud Factor X at my favourite grow store and I picked it up on the way to my niece's wedding yesterday expecting to pay around $30-$50 for it. Free sample I was told. Nothing better than free so it's no wonder I do my shopping there! :)

At another grow store they have 4 - 1000W MH/HPS used magnetic ballasts for $75 ea and a few used Light Rails with meter long rails asking $175 ea. Same guy that works at the store is selling those and has other stuff so will be dropping by to see him this week as he works weekdays only. Prices are negotiable.

Going to have to hit mommy up for another loan against my inheritance. 10G ought to do it. 2g on grow gear, 4-5G for a decent vehicle to haul the grow gear back north and the rest for home repair etc. Her 90th today.
 

Yodaweed

Well-Known Member
Dry nutes are generally fine unles theyharden up then I just toss it in the composter or outside where my garden goes
Those will kill the microbial life in your compost , i wouldn't put salts in a compost. Also they are really not good to allow to drain into your water supply. Farm fertilizer run off, That's what you are doing when you do that, it's not only bad for you but also bad for your community.
 

OldMedUser

Well-Known Member
I don't believe chemical salt has an expiration date.
Why call it chemical salt? All salts are chemical whether organic or inorganic. All life and inanimate things are chemical. Chemicals are the basis of everything yet the people spit when they say "chemical" this or that like it's a bad thing.

It's how the various chemicals are combined to make compounds that determines whether they are safe or toxic. There are millions of chemical reactions going on in your body 24/7.

There are thousands, if not millions of salt compounds.

Those will kill the microbial life in your compost
That my friend is totally wrong unless you overdose with salts. Scare mongering.
 

Yodaweed

Well-Known Member
Why call it chemical salt? All salts are chemical whether organic or inorganic. All life and inanimate things are chemical. Chemicals are the basis of everything yet the people spit when they say "chemical" this or that like it's a bad thing.

It's how the various chemicals are combined to make compounds that determines whether they are safe or toxic. There are millions of chemical reactions going on in your body 24/7.

There are thousands, if not millions of salt compounds.



That my friend is totally wrong unless you overdose with salts. Scare mongering.
Any amount of salts in organic soil will harm microbial life, you might wanna read up on soil science, i'd start with teaming with microbes.
 

SouthCross

Well-Known Member
Why call it chemical salt? All salts are chemical whether organic or inorganic. All life and inanimate things are chemical. Chemicals are the basis of everything yet the people spit when they say "chemical" this or that like it's a bad thing.

It's how the various chemicals are combined to make compounds that determines whether they are safe or toxic. There are millions of chemical reactions going on in your body 24/7.

There are thousands, if not millions of salt compounds.



That my friend is totally wrong unless you overdose with salts. Scare mongering.

Ok. Ill call it synthetic fertilizer from now on. Wouldn't want people getting scared(?)...
 

AimAim

Well-Known Member
Any amount of salts in organic soil will harm microbial life, you might wanna read up on soil science, i'd start with teaming with microbes.
Well, generally salts are the form of nutrients available in the soil solution. Perhaps you need to learn / understand what salts are. They are ionic solutions formed by a reaction between acids and bases. The H+ portion of the an acid is replaced by by a metal (usually) cation. NaCl is of course the basic "salt" we identify with, but there are hundreds of other salt solutions beneficial to plants. Hell required.

Your growing medium, if it is healthy, has many "salts" in the soil solution.
 

Yodaweed

Well-Known Member
Well, generally salts are the form of nutrients available in the soil solution. Perhaps you need to learn / understand what salts are. They are ionic solutions formed by a reaction between acids and bases. The H+ portion of the an acid is replaced by by a metal (usually) cation. NaCl is of course the basic "salt" we identify with, but there are hundreds of other salt solutions beneficial to plants. Hell required.

Your growing medium, if it is healthy, has many "salts" in the soil solution.
There's a huge difference between small amounts of salt ion's produced and pouring harmful caustic chemical salts on your soil. There's a reason you shouldn't even be pouring this stuff down the drain, it is very harmful and cancer causing. This stuff also completely destroys your soil, after using salts the soil is damaged beyond repair, the only way for plants to continue to grow in it is to use more salts, which not only destroys the soil but also runs off into water supplies causing contaiminated water.
 

AimAim

Well-Known Member
There's a huge difference between small amounts of salt ion's produced and pouring harmful caustic chemical salts on your soil. There's a reason you shouldn't even be pouring this stuff down the drain, it is very harmful and cancer causing.
OK. Fine.

What is the "stuff" being poured down the drain ? That is "very harmful" ?

Oh, yes, salts. Now I get it.
 

OldMedUser

Well-Known Member
There's a huge difference between small amounts of salt ion's produced and pouring harmful caustic chemical salts on your soil. There's a reason you shouldn't even be pouring this stuff down the drain, it is very harmful and cancer causing.
Now there's some trump inspired scare mongering if I've ever read it.

The pink Himalayan sea salt I use lots of every day is 42% NaCl and the rest is 83 other mineral salts. Before you get on your soapbox about the dangers of consuming salt you should know that I suffer from dangerously low blood pressure on occasion and the only treatment is more salt and caffeine.

Like most people I have avoided excess salt thru my adult life and now that I'm almost 63 the low BP I have had since a child is becoming chronic and could actually cause my demise.

Salts causing cancer? I'm sure there are some that could. Hopefully those kind of salts aren't used in decent grow nutes but ones like Miracle-Gro and Shultze's are known to have high levels of heavy metals that come in the form of salts due to the low quality of their sources for manufacture.

Salts are not caustic either unless they are salts like NaOH/caustic soda/lye/sodium hydroxide. There are lots of acid salts too.

Your use of chemical terminology betrays your ignorance in the chemical sciences so maybe it's best to remain silent and be thought a fool than by speaking up remove all traces of doubt. ;)
 

Yodaweed

Well-Known Member
Now there's some trump inspired scare mongering if I've ever read it.

The pink Himalayan sea salt I use lots of every day is 42% NaCl and the rest is 83 other mineral salts. Before you get on your soapbox about the dangers of consuming salt you should know that I suffer from dangerously low blood pressure on occasion and the only treatment is more salt and caffeine.

Like most people I have avoided excess salt thru my adult life and now that I'm almost 63 the low BP I have had since a child is becoming chronic and could actually cause my demise.

Salts causing cancer? I'm sure there are some that could. Hopefully those kind of salts aren't used in decent grow nutes but ones like Miracle-Gro and Shultze's are known to have high levels of heavy metals that come in the form of salts due to the low quality of their sources for manufacture.

Salts are not caustic either unless they are salts like NaOH/caustic soda/lye/sodium hydroxide. There are lots of acid salts too.

Your use of chemical terminology betrays your ignorance in the chemical sciences so maybe it's best to remain silent and be thought a fool than by speaking up remove all traces of doubt. ;)
The salts used in fertilizers are extremely toxic, that's why it's advised to not put them down the drain, i think you totally are clueless about what i am talking about. Table salt is totally different than salts used to make fertilizers.

You really should get some education about what you are using to grow your plants.
 
Top