600w vs. 1000w hps

Buddy Ganga

Active Member
I'm not saying you're wrong. It's pretty common knowledge that us humans breathe in oxygen, and exhale Co2. What I'm saying is that unless you're growing a 12 inch dwarf in a shoebox, it isn't a very effective way of supplementing your grow.

I suppose you could try and empty the ocean with a teaspoon too, but that probably wouldn't be very effective either.
Where did you get anything about supplementing a grow ?
It's a way for people to see the difference, answering any questions they could have about how effective a co2 set up will be..
I'm pretty sure I said to "one top or nug", yes, yes I did..

Besides, why are you trolling comments I make to other posters question especially when it's obvious you don't understand the point being made ?
 

Clonex

Well-Known Member
Where did you get anything about supplementing a grow ?
It's a way for people to see the difference, answering any questions they could have about how effective a co2 set up will be..
I'm pretty sure I said to "one top or nug", yes, yes I did..

Besides, why are you trolling comments I make to other posters question especially when it's obvious you don't understand the point being made ?
are you really of the opinion that breathing on 1 of your budds would affect it enough that you would see a difference with the naked eye ?
In my view the amount of co2 already existing in the Air would be far greater than the amount your breath could produce say once a day over a whole bloom period , my guess is it would be so tiny it would make no difference , bear in mind i have done a test on how much a litre bottle with yeast and sugar actually produces , any idea ? or were you not indeed being serious ?
 

stumpjumper

Well-Known Member
If you have fresh air continuously entering your room your plants do not need supplemental Co2.. Not saying it wont increase your crop, but it is no different than growing outdoors...

If you have a sealed environment with no fresh air intake then the plant will use up what is available and need more..
 

Buddy Ganga

Active Member
are you really of the opinion that breathing on 1 of your budds would affect it enough that you would see a difference with the naked eye ?
In my view the amount of co2 already existing in the Air would be far greater than the amount your breath could produce say once a day over a whole bloom period , my guess is it would be so tiny it would make no difference , bear in mind i have done a test on how much a litre bottle with yeast and sugar actually produces , any idea ? or were you not indeed being serious ?
Sorry man but you crack me up.
What I suggested is suggested by just about every good salesman out there dealing with skeptics asking about co2.

I guess this is where I go un fuck myself.
 

Clonex

Well-Known Member
Sorry man but you crack me up.
What I suggested is suggested by just about every good salesman out there dealing with skeptics asking about co2.

I guess this is where I go un fuck myself.
lol , i just wondered what your opinion was , Op to Op , no salesman.

I thought i thought i already un - fucked you....
 

kindfarms420

Active Member
1. i run 1000 watters in both my bloom rooms both are 4k each all are in raptors and both covering 8x8 canopy in a 10x10 room run co2 at 1200-1300 ppm while lights are on. in my veg i run 3 400 watt hortilux blue bulbs on a light mover in radiant reflectors most plants have a 2 month veg and the bulbs in the flower room are hortilux super hps bulbs. my yeild per plant on average is 15 ounces some strains i yeild up to 23 oz per plant lowest is 12oz per. i have used 600s and i wouldn't again unless i used 2 600s in place of 1 1000.

2. Buddy Ganga when i am working in my room with the lights on i turn off my co2 and my monitor will read 400ppm and i work in there for an hour the ppm has raised up to almost 800ppm so i agree that just by breathing will increase the ppm more then people think
 

gladstoned

Well-Known Member
I would love some pics. I have enough room to do exactly that. Do you use a flip box between your bloom rooms then alternate the co2?
 

Clonex

Well-Known Member
2. Buddy Ganga when i am working in my room with the lights on i turn off my co2 and my monitor will read 400ppm and i work in there for an hour the ppm has raised up to almost 800ppm so i agree that just by breathing will increase the ppm more then people think[/QUOTE]

Really lol , you keep telling yourself that !
 

kindfarms420

Active Member
2. Buddy Ganga when i am working in my room with the lights on i turn off my co2 and my monitor will read 400ppm and i work in there for an hour the ppm has raised up to almost 800ppm so i agree that just by breathing will increase the ppm more then people think
Really lol , you keep telling yourself that ![/QUOTE]

dude i have more than one digital co2 monitor in both my rooms i dont think both of them would go from 400ppm to 800ppm when there isn't co2 running and if you think you still know that it wouldn't do that then buy one and test it yourself..im not here to argue but when there is proof in front of my eyes i believe it
 

Clonex

Well-Known Member
Really lol , you keep telling yourself that !
dude i have more than one digital co2 monitor in both my rooms i dont think both of them would go from 400ppm to 800ppm when there isn't co2 running and if you think you still know that it wouldn't do that then buy one and test it yourself..im not here to argue but when there is proof in front of my eyes i believe it[/QUOTE]
I have some thanks and ok (Y)
 

kindfarms420

Active Member
I would love some pics. I have enough room to do exactly that. Do you use a flip box between your bloom rooms then alternate the co2?

no pics at the moment im getting a camera soon.. i dont use a flip box ive heard there kinda shitty but i dont have personal experience with them.. and the co2 is completely seperate i run a 50lb tank in each room if i was in a garage or pole barn id use a co2 burner but i dont have enough room to run one right now
 

kindfarms420

Active Member
dude i have more than one digital co2 monitor in both my rooms i dont think both of them would go from 400ppm to 800ppm when there isn't co2 running and if you think you still know that it wouldn't do that then buy one and test it yourself..im not here to argue but when there is proof in front of my eyes i believe it
I have some thanks and ok (Y)[/QUOTE]
then if your room is sealed and you stand in it working for an hour it the ppms will rise... im not here to argue im just stateing a true fact
 

Clonex

Well-Known Member
I have some thanks and ok (Y)
then if your room is sealed and you stand in it working for an hour it the ppms will rise... im not here to argue im just stateing a true fact[/QUOTE]

Im not doubting it will rise , i know this , your figures are out , thats all.
 

Clonex

Well-Known Member
Clonex is nothing more then a TROLL.
If you do not feed the troll it will leave.
Why am i a troll ,
the Op is saying an hour spent in his bloom room , he gained 400 ppm from his breath,
oh i know i will just accept it so i am not insulted by a 10 post randomer,
get a grip.
 

st0wandgrow

Well-Known Member
1. i run 1000 watters in both my bloom rooms both are 4k each all are in raptors and both covering 8x8 canopy in a 10x10 room run co2 at 1200-1300 ppm while lights are on. in my veg i run 3 400 watt hortilux blue bulbs on a light mover in radiant reflectors most plants have a 2 month veg and the bulbs in the flower room are hortilux super hps bulbs. my yeild per plant on average is 15 ounces some strains i yeild up to 23 oz per plant lowest is 12oz per. i have used 600s and i wouldn't again unless i used 2 600s in place of 1 1000.




2. Buddy Ganga when i am working in my room with the lights on i turn off my co2 and my monitor will read 400ppm and i work in there for an hour the ppm has raised up to almost 800ppm so i agree that just by breathing will increase the ppm more then people think

I'm staying out of this! lol

Let's just all agree that Co2 is a good thing for the girls. :-)
 

Buddy Ganga

Active Member
Kindfarms420,

Tell me about the "blues" if you would, we've been thinking about trying them out but really want to hear from someone that's actually using them to find out if they are really what they seem.. Right now we are running ushio's and other then the extra heat they put off we love em, but still want to see what the blues do.
 

Clonex

Well-Known Member
You have nothing to offer this discussion.
You are only here to argue with anyone willing to reply.
TROLL!
Then you obviously struggle reading ,
if you have no food for the troll why are you bothering me ,
pass across my bridge quietly ,

Everybody talks rubbish sometimes,
dont' shoot the messenger for pointing it out,
keep your insults to yourself,
my points were relavent , even if it's not what you want to hear!!
 
Top