Sterile or Bennie's?

nicksol86

Well-Known Member
Do you run sterile? hydroguard? brew your own beneficial tea? or do you not use the sterile route or Bennie's and just wish for the best? What do you use and why do you go that route? I'm using hydroguard currently but plan to brew some tea when I get some mollases and zho powder or great white. I chose the hydroguard way to fight root rot. I don't have a whole lot of knowledge on Bennie's verses sterile so wanted to learn what you all do. I have h202 and sodium hypoclorite if I ever wanna go sterile route. But I hear that Bennie's are better? Go...
 

Logan Burke

Well-Known Member
Bennies, in my opinion, are the best by far! To sterilize is to attempt to kill all microbial life both good and bad, and too keep them gone...this is hard enough, but then you have the fact that the good microbials break down the oh-so-annoying leaf tips getting torn off and dropping in your res into ready-to-use nutes for your plant, not to mention keeping it from wreaking havoc on your ph and feeding loads of bad bacteria (because the bennies keep the bad bacteria beaten down and in check). I've only had about five DWC grows, so I'm definitely not a veteran user like many other posters. But I have tried running sterile and it ended disastrously. I used to run Hydroguard, with great success, the stuff is a lifesaver. But I decided to try Great White and oh boy...it is even better. I mean honestly the results are astoundingly different, however, the Great White contains the same bacicullus strain as the Hydroguard does, as well as dozens or more other beneficial microbes like your Rhizos, and others I cannot pronounce lmao. I have no experience with benny tea, but putting your roots in some tea during a res change I would imagine would be pretty helpful to your plants. Sorry, I'm a motormouth, lmao.
 

nicksol86

Well-Known Member
Bennies, in my opinion, are the best by far! To sterilize is to attempt to kill all microbial life both good and bad, and too keep them gone...this is hard enough, but then you have the fact that the good microbials break down the oh-so-annoying leaf tips getting torn off and dropping in your res into ready-to-use nutes for your plant, not to mention keeping it from wreaking havoc on your ph and feeding loads of bad bacteria (because the bennies keep the bad bacteria beaten down and in check). I've only had about five DWC grows, so I'm definitely not a veteran user like many other posters. But I have tried running sterile and it ended disastrously. I used to run Hydroguard, with great success, the stuff is a lifesaver. But I decided to try Great White and oh boy...it is even better. I mean honestly the results are astoundingly different, however, the Great White contains the same bacicullus strain as the Hydroguard does, as well as dozens or more other beneficial microbes like your Rhizos, and others I cannot pronounce lmao. I have no experience with benny tea, but putting your roots in some tea during a res change I would imagine would be pretty helpful to your plants. Sorry, I'm a motormouth, lmao.
No thanks , I appreciate the feedback. You nailed it I think on what I was asking. My friend uses sterile everytime with sodium hypoclorite and has great success. But you have some valid points. So far I'm digging the Bennie route myself just using hydrolysed. I hear great things about great white. Might have to order some. How much great white you use per gallon?
 

Logan Burke

Well-Known Member
Totally understandable! I think temperature is really the biggest factor of it all. With correct temps I'd say most of all root rot isn't an issue. Well it calls for 1/2 a teaspoon for every ten gallons, and each of my 5gal buckets keeps about 3+ gallons of water, but I personally go a bit over-kill and about 1/4 of a teaspoon to each bucket. Then re-add another dose about 7-10 days later. The stuff is pretty cheap, a 30$ supply will last my 6 bucket the whole grow.
 

nicksol86

Well-Known Member
I use just cool water temps i keep my temp below 68 at all times and never get root tor ive had it before but once i got my temps under control no problems at all
I've got rot with temps between 60 and 70. Not sure if it was high water level or fungus gnats but I had a plant die that nothing would save. Not even hydroguard or h202, nothing I did worked on her so I threw her away unfortunately and started over. So far so good this run. White roots in every bucket.
 

nicksol86

Well-Known Member
Pic of the room today. Diesel berry auto showing preflowers already so put the 1000 watt hps light going today. 3 more will be getting transplanted into there now homes today or tomorrow. Will have a total of 6 autos. 2 diesel berry autos from auto seeds. 1 auto kush from female seeds, 1 auto speed bud from female seeds, 1 amnesia xxl auto from dinafem and 1 sour diesel auto from Humboldt seed organization. 5 different strains in 6 buckets. Next run I'll be doing all new strains. Which will be 4 strains from barneys farm and 3 strains from sweet seeds. So I need to get another 5 gallon bucket.
 

Attachments

Neville Longbottom

Active Member
Pic of the room today. Diesel berry auto showing preflowers already so put the 1000 watt hps light going today. 3 more will be getting transplanted into there now homes today or tomorrow. Will have a total of 6 autos. 2 diesel berry autos from auto seeds. 1 auto kush from female seeds, 1 auto speed bud from female seeds, 1 amnesia xxl auto from dinafem and 1 sour diesel auto from Humboldt seed organization. 5 different strains in 6 buckets. Next run I'll be doing all new strains. Which will be 4 strains from barneys farm and 3 strains from sweet seeds. So I need to get another 5 gallon bucket.
Pic of my hydro room today 4 weeks into bud nothing but cool temps to keep the root rot away.
 

Attachments

projectinfo

Well-Known Member
Look into southern ag, garden friendly fungicide . 1ml per 15 gals.

Exact same ingredient as hydroguard , only over 100x as potent

Nutrient conpanys water shit down and rebottle and sell to growers for 50x the price . Dont be fooled by the snake oil. Most of the stuff we all use have different applocations in the real world.

You just have to be crafty and do the research
 

ConMer710

Member
I current have a DWC system and run bennies. I use mycogrow by fungi perfect it is really nice but a little to pricey for my to add them every couple days. They do have big bag for more bulk pricing.

I am thinking of switching to hydro guard for daily use use the mycogrow as a booster.
 

projectinfo

Well-Known Member
I current have a DWC system and run bennies. I use mycogrow by fungi perfect it is really nice but a little to pricey for my to add them every couple days. They do have big bag for more bulk pricing.

I am thinking of switching to hydro guard for daily use use the mycogrow as a booster.
Go to southern ag, garden friendly fungicide i use 1 ml per week compared to 40ml of hydroguard.

And its like a third of the price

Do the resesrch lots of people use it Ive been using it for 4 months
 

nicksol86

Well-Known Member
Go to southern ag, garden friendly fungicide i use 1 ml per week compared to 40ml of hydroguard.

And its like a third of the price

Do the resesrch lots of people use it Ive been using it for 4 months
A small bottle of hydroguard is pretty cheap though and its lasted me 2 cycles.
 

nicksol86

Well-Known Member
I've been lucky enough using just water and nutrients. I use this because it's simple and cheap and works for me and my room.
your lucky, root rot is hell for gardeners. haha, im doing fine with just hydroguard for now but adding bennies to my system asap.
 

ConMer710

Member
If you look at the ingredients it is the same as hydroguard so I'll give it s try. It It cheaper and in have seen other people using it so why not.
 

Billy Liar

Well-Known Member
It's good to implement as many modes of action as possible to prevent waterborne pathogens whilst running the optimal temperatures for the metabolic processes in the root zone.
Im running Bacterial and mechanical filtration, UV sterilisation, and bacterial colonisation of the roots. I'm looking into possibly building a pasteurisation unit too.

The UV sterilisation can cause Fe issues so this must be fixed if used. Ozone treatment will also cause issues like this.

Peace
BL
 
Top