I'm not a fan of tubes due to size/space... (well T12s anyhow) T5's rock but their just not cheap enough.
But a 2ft 20 watt T12 puts out MAX, 1250 lumens where as a 23 watt CFL will put out 1600-1750 lumens. And with T12's... soft whites net the most lumens per watt (at 1250) but something like a daylight tube only put out 1025 lumens.