The second chart looks better, but the grow amounts seem low, unless they are talking about starting from clones. Without K-L-N and a decent amount of light you can run grow at 12-15 ml in recirc and the plants look PERFECT - dark green but not too dark and with perfect tips.
The second cart runs Bloom to Mag Pro at around 5:1 - 6:1, the first one runs it in near equal parts, WAY to much Mag Pro, not near enough bloom.