Chromaticity Region ?

PilouPilou

Well-Known Member
Hi all!

Someone knows what is the difference between 3-Step MacAdam Ellipse and 5-Step MacAdam Ellipse.

I noticed that the 5-step chips are a bit more efficient (lm/Watt).

Thx!
 
Hi all!

Someone knows what is the difference between 3-Step MacAdam Ellipse and 5-Step MacAdam Ellipse.

I noticed that the 5-step chips are a bit more efficient (lm/Watt).

Thx!
Imagine that the exact color(say 3000K), is at point X=0.4328 Y=0.4064 on the CIE/blackbody curve. That is "actual 3000K" for this example. Now imagine that is the bulls eye and there are rings that "step" out from that center point. Each ring or step is a deviation away from actual 3000K bullseye.
These "steps" are tiny, and it takes between 2 and 3 steps for humans to see a difference in white light usually, and is very small at best. But what the plant see/think is what matters, and they don''t care...and probably prefer the wider possibilities of more nm's of light from a wide color bin. But really should make 0 difference for the plants.

These McAdams bin steps are for the visual aesthetic world where if a human was walking down a hallway or street...every light/bulb/fixture would appear the exact same color to the eyes. Having a 4500K in a row of 5000K would stand out in a nice building.

Higher step bins are usually cheaper too.

Really doesn't matter, it's up to you and availability of what you can get.
 
Imagine that the exact color(say 3000K), is at point X=0.4328 Y=0.4064 on the CIE/blackbody curve. That is "actual 3000K" for this example. Now imagine that is the bulls eye and there are rings that "step" out from that center point. Each ring or step is a deviation away from actual 3000K bullseye.
These "steps" are tiny, and it takes between 2 and 3 steps for humans to see a difference in white light usually, and is very small at best. But what the plant see/think is what matters, and they don''t care...and probably prefer the wider possibilities of more nm's of light from a wide color bin. But really should make 0 difference for the plants.

These McAdams bin steps are for the visual aesthetic world where if a human was walking down a hallway or street...every light/bulb/fixture would appear the exact same color to the eyes. Having a 4500K in a row of 5000K would stand out in a nice building.

Higher step bins are usually cheaper too.

Really doesn't matter, it's up to you and availability of what you can get.


Thank you very much @Greengenes707 .. I could not have a better reply.. a pro reply!
I understand better now the circles in the chromaticity section of datasheets. In fact, my question was inspired by digikey test of lm301B because I noticed that a same CCT had a little bit more lm/Watt when 5-step.

PS: your new light really rocks!
 
Back
Top