No facts, sources or logical . I guess opinions is ur core of reasons?
Got it! Here’s a fact-based, powerful rebuttal you can use in a comment, post, or debate reply. It directly responds to the opinion you quoted, without being emotional—just sharp, informed, and ethical.
REBUTTAL: Why Mass Deportation & Dehumanization of Undocumented Immigrants Is Wrong – Ethically, Economically, and Constitutionally
You’re entitled to your opinion—but when that opinion claims some people “matter less” and should be removed “by any means,” it crosses from opinion into dangerous policy justification with real-world harm.
Here are the facts: 1.
Undocumented Immigrants Are Not an Economic Burden—They’re Essential
- They pay ~$20 billion in taxes each year, including into Social Security and Medicare, which they can’t even use.
Source: Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP)
- Over 70% of all U.S. farmworkers are undocumented—removing them would collapse agriculture and drive food prices up.
Source: USDA
- Deporting all 11M+ undocumented immigrants would cost over $100–200 billion and shrink U.S. GDP by ~2.6%.
Source: American Action Forum, Cato Institute
So economically, mass deportation makes no sense. It’s not saving money—it’s burning tax dollars to remove the people who hold up entire industries.

2. U.S. Law Protects People, Not Just Citizens
- The Constitution guarantees due process and equal protection to persons on U.S. soil, not just citizens (14th Amendment, 5th Amendment).
- Dehumanizing immigrants—saying they “matter less”—has historical parallels to slavery, internment, and genocide.
- Human rights aren’t a zero-sum game: valuing others does not devalue Americans.

3. ICE Is Inefficient, Abusive, and Built on Political Theater
- ICE detains people at $140–300 per day, while humane alternatives cost less than $5/day and get 95% court compliance.
- Over 5,500 children were forcibly separated from their parents under “zero tolerance” policies—many were never reunited.
Source: ACLU, DHS OIG
- ICE has a long history of mistaken raids, abuses, wrongful detentions, and even death due to medical neglect.
So yes—we absolutely should question why ICE operates the way it does.
4. “Illegals harm society” Is Not Backed by Data
- Immigrants (legal or not) are less likely to commit crimes than U.S. citizens.
Source: Cato Institute, National Academy of Sciences
- You don’t solve child trafficking or cartel violence by criminalizing the victims of those very threats.
Let’s stop conflating undocumented families with criminals. It’s a tired narrative that only serves fear-based policy, not real solutions.

5. The Smart Solution? Immigration Reform—not Cruelty
Give long-time residents a pathway to legal status.
- Expand legal migration, work permits, and asylum processing.
- Invest in the root causes of migration (poverty, war, climate).
- Focus ICE on real threats, not peaceful families.
Final Thought:
Saying undocumented immigrants “matter less” isn’t just an opinion—it’s a worldview rooted in dehumanization. It’s economically flawed, morally indefensible, and historically dangerous.
America was built by immigrants. Protecting our laws and borders does not require cruelty or mass deportation—it requires policy grounded in reality, humanity, and constitutional values.