do you personally plant seeds with the root up or down?

i planted mine with the root down 48hrs ago, and still no sign.

the first 24hours i left in a dark warm place, now i have put a light over the pot.

why do some people say plant up, and some say down?

what do you do?

?

Always plant the roots downnnnnnnnnn

Yep, roots down. Have you ever seen a plant grow with it's roots coming out of the ground and it's leaves growing underground?

i hate this question. it doesn't HAVE to be facing a certain way. taproots are made to orient themselves. in nature do seeds randomly fall or do plants carefully place them underground facing a certain way? i'm pretty sure the plant knows what its doing better than any of us could hope to.

(ps. i didn't mean to sound offensive if i came off that way.)

makes sense to plant down as thats the way its going to go, but if u plant up it will still end up curling and growing down.

also : gotta give it more than 48 hours man, how far down did u plant the seed?

freddythekruger said:

i hate this question. it doesn't HAVE to be facing a certain way. taproots are made to orient themselves. in nature do seeds randomly fall or do plants carefully place them underground facing a certain way? i'm pretty sure the plant knows what its doing better than any of us could hope to.

Click to expand...

Well, that's a bit like saying if you drop a cat upside down it will fall on it's feet but that doesn't mean the cat likes it. I can lend support to your statement though since I've had seeds where the tap root grows up and down and sideways all at once.

That being said it's best to put the tap root down so the plant doesn't have to grow around it and try to move itself back around to the up position.

freddythekruger said:

i hate this question. it doesn't HAVE to be facing a certain way. taproots are made to orient themselves. in nature do seeds randomly fall or do plants carefully place them underground facing a certain way? i'm pretty sure the plant knows what its doing better than any of us could hope to.

(ps. i didn't mean to sound offensive if i came off that way.)

Click to expand...

but the less the plant has to work then the better right?

juststartin said:

also : gotta give it more than 48 hours man, how far down did u plant the seed?

Click to expand...

dude, im not gonna lie, im a fukin noob.

planted them 2 inches like an idiot, i dug up the top layers of soil about 3 hours ago, till i could see the leaves, then i put a tiny layer over them, because they should be up soon.

there about half a centimeter from the surface, hope i didn't damage them too much by spooning out the soil around them

will put pics on my journal soon.

I'm sure there are 101 reasons not to do it this way but I germinate until the root is about 2 full inches long and plant it with the root down and the shell of the seed sticking a little out of the dirt. That way I can moniter the growth immediately and help the shell peel off by hand when it is ready. When i do this you can see the growth within 24 hours.