Aliens

Padawanbater2

Padawanbater2

Well-Known Member
Chief Walkin Eagle said:
Experience says otherwise, but even then you can label us as delusional because you assume what we experience is a trick of the mind, jumping to conclusions, or desperately trying to give meaning to something that we want to be true. But this is one of those classic arguments between atheists and theists that will never end because our experiences mean nothing to you, doesnt prove anything. Its pointless to continue discussing because we both are convinced that our point of view is the more accurate one.
Click to expand...
You must acknowledge that anecdotal evidence isn't applicable to modern science. It isn't us assuming anything, there are very good reasons why we simply can't take someones word for something, and if we did, the science that followed would be inherently flawed. It has nothing to do with anything else, we wouldn't end up with accurate science if that's how it was done.

Experiences are 100% subjective to the person experiencing them. You walk into a room and you're cold, I could walk into the same exact room and feel hot, depending on many different variables. What you are proposing atheists and critical thinkers do is dismiss objective observation in favor of subjective interpretation. You would end up with thousands of different viewpoints (consider how many people have how many differing opinions about something like politics or economics) that wouldn't lead to anything useful.

Do you understand that explanation?
 
Chief Walkin Eagle

Chief Walkin Eagle

Well-Known Member
Padawanbater2 said:
You must acknowledge that anecdotal evidence isn't applicable to modern science. It isn't us assuming anything, there are very good reasons why we simply can't take someones word for something, and if we did, the science that followed would be inherently flawed. It has nothing to do with anything else, we wouldn't end up with accurate science if that's how it was done.

Experiences are 100% subjective to the person experiencing them. You walk into a room and you're cold, I could walk into the same exact room and feel hot, depending on many different variables. What you are proposing atheists and critical thinkers do is dismiss objective observation in favor of subjective interpretation. You would end up with thousands of different viewpoints (consider how many people have how many differing opinions about something like politics or economics) that wouldn't lead to anything useful.

Do you understand that explanation?
Click to expand...
I said that our experiences prove nothing, because thats what they are, OUR experiences, not yours.
 
Corso312

Corso312

Well-Known Member
Chief Walkin Eagle said:
Me and my buddy looked up one night and seen that the star Sirius was not there, like what the fucking fuck? I almost shit my pants when I seen that. Sure enough the next clear night it was there... I seen a lot more shit but thats the only one you'd have a chance at believing lol.
Click to expand...


i am no scientist...i assume there could be an explanation from a scientist ?....i know nothing about the stars..perhaps you were looking in a different direction?
 
Corso312

Corso312

Well-Known Member
clouds sounds plausible ....if you watch some of these people tell their bigfoot stories/photos...they actually believe it, most are not crazy people...they are just mistaken
 
Chief Walkin Eagle

Chief Walkin Eagle

Well-Known Member
Corso312 said:
i am no scientist...i assume there could be an explanation from a scientist ?....i know nothing about the stars..perhaps you were looking in a different direction?
Click to expand...
Nah I know basic astronomy (very basic) I just know the position of most of the major stars so theres no way my eyes were mistaken. The three main stars in Orions Belt point down at Sirius and Sirius is always in that area. Sirius is one of the brightest stars in the sky so it should of been clearly visible when viewed from 20 minutes out of town on a clear night. If you have access to clear skys than I suggest you start star gazing more, crazy shit has been happening up there recently, talking about it proves nothing, people just need to look up.
 
Corso312

Corso312

Well-Known Member
ok...im gonna go smoke and take a peek in the sky....just moved to michigan from chicago so i should see things i could not before...it is raining here though
 
Padawanbater2

Padawanbater2

Well-Known Member
Chief Walkin Eagle said:
I said that our experiences prove nothing, because thats what they are, OUR experiences, not yours.
Click to expand...
It seems like you're implying that personal experiences are as valuable to the pursuit of truth as objective observation and experimentation. It's not an 'us v. them' kind of thing, it's a 'one has valid evidence v. one with no valid evidence'; evolution v. creation for example.

Can something be true without any evidence that it is?
 
Padawanbater2

Padawanbater2

Well-Known Member
Chief Walkin Eagle said:
Nah I know basic astronomy (very basic) I just know the position of most of the major stars so theres no way my eyes were mistaken. The three main stars in Orions Belt point down at Sirius and Sirius is always in that area. Sirius is one of the brightest stars in the sky so it should of been clearly visible when viewed from 20 minutes out of town on a clear night. If you have access to clear skys than I suggest you start star gazing more, crazy shit has been happening up there recently, talking about it proves nothing, people just need to look up.
Click to expand...
Why didn't you take a picture of this? If I noticed a star missing in the sky, first thing I would do is take a picture.
 
Chief Walkin Eagle

Chief Walkin Eagle

Well-Known Member
Zaehet Strife said:
If they prove nothing, how can you be so certain of them being true? The truth is, you can't... can't handle the truth.
Click to expand...
It proves nothing to YOU, especially you lol the lucid dreamer. If something like lucid dreaming cant open your eyes to anything then Im guessing it would take something quite astonishing for you to consider the possibility of spirit... But like I said, this argument goes nowhere and it never does.
 
mindphuk

mindphuk

Well-Known Member
Chief Walkin Eagle said:
Me and my buddy looked up one night and seen that the star Sirius was not there, like what the fucking fuck? I almost shit my pants when I seen that. Sure enough the next clear night it was there... I seen a lot more shit but thats the only one you'd have a chance at believing lol.
Click to expand...
much more likely it was cloud cover. Of course you would still believe it went missing in spite of no reports from any astronomers, amateur or professional because you know the spiritual realm and you are an unfallible observer. Do you honestly believe something like that would go unnoticed?
 
Chief Walkin Eagle

Chief Walkin Eagle

Well-Known Member
mindphuk said:
much more likely it was cloud cover. Of course you would still believe it went missing in spite of no reports from any astronomers, amateur or professional. Do you honestly believe something like that would go unnoticed?
Click to expand...
No clouds my friend, just clear skys. You'd think this tiny invisible cloud you speak of would move out of the way after a while. And I was shocked that this went un-noticed, it had to of been seen by at least one astronomer. My explanation for that is maybe they are told to keep their mouths shut so they dont want the population freaking out. I think people would start believing that dec 21st is really the end (which I dont believe) if they knew that stars were flying around.
 
mindphuk

mindphuk

Well-Known Member
Chief Walkin Eagle said:
No clouds my friend, just clear skys. You'd think this tiny invisible cloud you speak of would move out of the way after a while. And I was shocked that this went un-noticed, it had to of been seen by at least one astronomer. My explanation for that is maybe they are told to keep their mouths shut so they dont want the population freaking out. I think people would start believing that dec 21st is really the end (which I dont believe) if they knew that stars were flying around.
Click to expand...
How can you be sure there wasn't a cloud? If you really watched the skies as often as you claim, you would know that most clouds are indeed invisible at night and yes, it might move out of the way after awhile but you said you left to go get a camera? Which is it? Did you stay and observe for an hour to see if the skies got progressively worse supporting the idea that clouds were moving in (or sirius made a sudden appearance when the cloud moved) or did you leave the viewing area and go get a camera?

So now the stars are flying around? It didn't just disappear?
 
Chief Walkin Eagle

Chief Walkin Eagle

Well-Known Member
mindphuk said:
How can you be sure there wasn't a cloud? If you really watched the skies as often as you claim, you would know that most clouds are indeed invisible at night and yes, it might move out of the way after awhile but you said you left to go get a camera? Which is it? Did you stay and observe for an hour to see if the skies got progressively worse supporting the idea that clouds were moving in (or sirius made a sudden appearance when the cloud moved) or did you leave the viewing area and go get a camera?

So now the stars are flying around? It didn't just disappear?
Click to expand...
lol calm down man, I got nothing to prove, Im just talking about what I seen. Me and others seen much more as well, this is one of the less astonishing things we witnessed, I just figured this would be easier to talk about.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top