Lost on Iraq

Democrats should admit that they want to give up.

By Rich Lowry


Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid had a bright, shining moment of honesty when he said that the war in Iraq is lost.

He unburdened himself of what he and many of his colleagues have long believed about the war. Now if only Democrats saw fit to continue with their truth-telling. Then they would acknowledge that their mandate for a U.S. withdrawal beginning in October is a policy predicated on our defeat, and that they don’t think anything can or should be done about Iran and al-Qaida feasting on a prostrate Iraq and the country possibly descending into genocidal bloodletting.

This position would be unimpeachably logical. It would accept, in the words Reid has repeated a lot lately, “facts and reality,” as Democrats see them. One could strenuously disagree with this position but still see a certain honor in its frankness and internal consistency.

Democrats, of course, are doing nothing of the kind. Instead, after Reid’s “lost” comment, they retreated back into their fog of evasion, contradictions and groan-inducing implausibilities. The party of defeat has a deep identity crisis because it can’t admit what it is, and thus lives a life of dishonesty and unconvincing denial.

Reid didn’t disavow his remark, but his spokesman said that in the future he will “couch it more.” Sen. Dianne Feinstein said that Reid had “more a problem of tone rather than of substance.” Democrats therefore have resolved themselves to find euphemisms for the word “lost.” Their current favorite is “there is no military solution in Iraq.”

Asked about his “lost” comment on CNN, Reid said, “I agree with Gen. Petraeus,” because Petraeus has said only part of the war is military. Saying that the war is multifaceted, however, bears no relation to the proposition that it is lost. Pressed on as to what message it sends to the troops to tell them the war is unwinnable, Reid said, “Gen. Petraeus has told them that.” Really? Reid apparently inhabits an alternate reality created by his need to weasel his way out of his own convictions on the war.

Reid doesn’t want to hear it if Petraeus has anything positive to say about the war. “I don’t believe him,” Reid said of Petraeus’ reports of progress. This is not surprising. Like many Democrats, Reid has a faith in defeat that is impervious to all contrary evidence. Acknowledging any fluidity in conditions in Iraq — say, how our position has improved in Anbar province in recent months — is to tacitly admit the folly of making final statements about defeat or victory. So Reid fixates on exactly the indicator that al-Qaida in Iraq wants him to — the spectacular suicide bombings meant to undermine our will.

To compensate for giving up on this war, Democrats conjure an imaginary Iraq War to which they will be utterly committed and which we will fight until glorious victory. That is the war we supposedly will fight against al-Qaida in Iraq — after, of course, we withdraw our troops and hand over the Anbar and Diyala provinces to it. Sen. Chuck Schumer, in Reid cleanup mode, says then we’ll be wondrously positioned to go “after an al-Qaida camp that might arise in Iraq.” Might? We already are engaged in a fight with al-Qaida in Iraq now — to keep it from stoking a full-scale sectarian war and from taking over swathes of Iraq — but the Democrats think that we’ve lost it.

“No one wants us to succeed in Iraq more than the Democrats,” Reid maintains. What a pathetic canard. As if believing a war is lost has no effect on your will to succeed in it. Reid might have been right if he had said the past tense, “wanted.”

Democrats are under no obligation to think the war can be won. But they should feel obliged to their consciences and voters to be forthright about what they believe. Waiting for them to do that seems the real lost cause.

© 2007 by King Features Syndicate

__________________
Liberals are people that will believe anything twice.

Conscience, conscience, we don't need no stinkin conscience.

__________________
Life is good, the water is sweet. The ground keeps moving beneath my feet.

That's it? Brilliant, Med.

Vi

__________________
Liberals are people that will believe anything twice.

Geeze thanks. No need in legitimizing your twisted opinions. I've done my homework and know the score, rant away. I refuse to argue with rhetorical bullshit. BTW I gave up in Iraq over a year ago, so all deaths since then are off my conscience.

__________________
Life is good, the water is sweet. The ground keeps moving beneath my feet.

that sounds like something a 9 year old would say.

because you gave up on your country the lives of soldiers don't matter... sort of like a famous man who washed his hands before the angry crowd.

if you have reason and fact on your side then please, for the first time, make it public.


.


.

__________________
"But even when you cease to be slaves, you are yet far removed from being placed on an equality with the white race."

- Abraham Lincoln, President of the United States of America, Hero to the servants of big government, Racist War Monger

You are a sick twisted puppie. I gave up on the administrations handling of their War. As a veteran of combat, I'd never give up on the troops. They are forced into Harms way by sick individuals like you that think war is a picnic or at least justifiable as long as you don't have to participate. Anyone that thinks war is right and just is an asshole in my mind. They should be the ones on the front lines. The only time war is justified is if you are invaded, kind of like how the Iraqis are justified in their insurgency, and no I don't condone the killing of American troops, but I don't blame that on the Iraqis, I blame that on Bush and his cohorts! BTW Reason and fact are only discernable to the receptor, if you can't understand reason then I guess you're not receptive, or put another way you are un-reasonable.

__________________
Life is good, the water is sweet. The ground keeps moving beneath my feet.

war is hard, it's not something to take lightly and it's certainly not something to intentionally lose.


.

__________________
"But even when you cease to be slaves, you are yet far removed from being placed on an equality with the white race."

- Abraham Lincoln, President of the United States of America, Hero to the servants of big government, Racist War Monger

You fail to see we've already lost. War in Iraq we cannot win. The only hope is to pull out and make peace with whoever comes out on top. Yeah a lot of people will die, a lot of people are dying as we speak, at least it won't be young sons and daughters of American mothers dying, fuck Iraq, here let me say it again, FUCK IRAQ!!!

__________________
Life is good, the water is sweet. The ground keeps moving beneath my feet.

Wassup, MedMan.

Troops are not "forced into harms way". They enlisted. Soldiers are supposed to fight (or is it ALL about the GI Bill?).

War is never just or right. However, war is always going to be reality.

I blame Bush and the right for their mis-handling of this war. If they would have shut their ears and not given in to the incessant ranting of the media and left wing pukes who made this war a "police action" (whatever the fuck you wanna call it). HE BLEW IT AND NOW WE ARE FUCKED.

I gotta go puff........

__________________
smokeit


I am only here to gather information for a friend of my brother. Pot do smoke not I.

Ramblerpimp ---->> Another voice of reason in the forum.

Vi

__________________
Liberals are people that will believe anything twice.