pretty much right.. just make sure the clone you choose is not extremely woody.. there is a technique I use that I find very beneficial to the mother and the clone. I have seen it adapted for MJ, but never actually seen it used in a journal/real life. Its where you wither bury a small portion of a limb (the portion you want roots on) and roots will grow on it. also, using clear plastic a couple pieces of string and soil you can tie a "bandage" on the plant, roots will form and you can take the clone. Remember, not all trees will make good bonsai.. If you find one you like and you don't know the name..post a pic. me of the best places to find wild bonsai are harsh conditioned areas such as on rocks while hiking, or in the gravel around rail road tracks (this is illegal.. not like it matters on this site).. anywhere the trees growth could be slightly stunted... clones are nice, but you want a real thick trunk.. the thicker the trunk the older the tree LOOKS. A good method to getting a large trunk from a clone is to take your clone and then plant it in the ground for about a year or more.. controlling height by pinching sprouts.. this will give you a hefty trunk that would take many years in a small dish.. Bonsai is fun, but its slow. Imagine how impatient you are for your plants to grow.. times that by about ten or twenty. Most importantly.. you WILL kill trees.. but this is how you learn.. get a good soil mix (mine has no organics) nothing too heavy.. no miracle grow, etc. and start giving it a try..

good luck man. let's see that mother.

__________________
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnZb5wi_jsU&NR=1

wow... that was horribly written. I think I'll proof read before I post sometime. Hopefully you got the just of that.

__________________
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnZb5wi_jsU&NR=1

and there another way to clone instead of cutting it down you can just strip the bark out of the branch you want to be clone wrap it with dirt in a plastic bag pack tight and then poke few holes in it you can put rooting power on the fresh strip branch before wrap it in dirt keep the dirt moist and in about 1-2 weeks there will be root develop at that part and you can cut it out and plant it on it own....you can do that with bigger tree and have great result....good luck!!!

__________________
RON PAUL FOR PRESIDENT!!! Our grow journal Rollitup.org streaming Live ( type that in search) radio

Dude, what are you talking about?? You can clone ANY bonsai. Willow is one of many trees which doesn't require any type of rooting hormone. It's only hard to train if you are using some type of thin copper wire (i.e. RJ11 et cetera). Bonsai are not limited to ONLY trees. Don't fool yourselves with the title of 'bonsai trees.' I have been growing bonsai for years, and I use a number of juniper, holly, and other shrubs/bushes to create such plants. According to: bonsai - Definitions from Dictionary.com

...it is a ..."a tree or shrub that has been dwarfed, as by pruning the roots and pinching, and is grown in a pot or other container and trained to produce a desired size/shape." It is nothing more than a dwarfed plant... not a tree. With the proper humidity (in say a clone dome), and the right rooting gel/powder/compound, you can clone any tree/shrub/plant. I've even cloned apple cuttings, cara cara cuttings, and california redwood cuttings (1/2" thick). It's all about the technique.

You can't clone any tree.Pines can't be cloned.

__________________
Peace, Love and Chicken grease.

Did you even read what I wrote? You pretty much repeated what I just said..

"it's only hard to train if your using some sort of thin copper wire" ... WHAT? Thats the only hard way to train a willow bonsai? Let me see if i can think of one.. You can hand it upside down and glue pennies to the branches if you want them to grow upward.. that sounds easier. Show me a picture of a willow bonsai that actually looks desirable.. you're into bonsai so I assume you know the five basic styles (windswept, formal upright, informal, cascade, and variation). Show me a picture of a willow that shows any of these styles. I have only seen one desirable willow bonsai.. EVER. Get on any bonsai forum and ask them if they like willow bonsai, you'll get laughed at.

I never told you you couldn't clone an apple tree. Fuck dude, you can clone anything, just ask Samuel Wood.

"It is nothing more than a dwarfed plant... not a tree." Read the first line of that definition you posted; "A tree or shrub..." By the way a tree is a shrub and visa versa..the only difference is characterization by size. "The tree form has evolved separately in unrelated classes of plants, in response to similar environmental challenges, making it a classic example of parallel evolution." -Wikipedia.

I too use junipers, they are easy, cheap and don't make you cry when you kill them. Keep in mind the most desirable and expensive trees are the ones that show classic style, age, and grown tree characteristics.


</IMG>

__________________
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnZb5wi_jsU&NR=1

Bonsai - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

just found this.. pretty much endorses what I just said.

__________________
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnZb5wi_jsU&NR=1

wow, apparently you have not thought about what I actually typed. You can in fact train the trunk of a willow, so you were incorrect in your o so valid assumption. Secondly, I did not repeat what you said, as you so boldly stated that a bonsai is in fact not a shrub, but a tree. Get your facts straight, bub. I have a number of japanese maples, roughly 20 years old which I have beautified in the style of jin.

Don't get your panties in a knot, if you reflect upon your first posting you stated that ..."depends on a lot of things...most important is tree type..." that was interpreted by myself (and I am sure others)that you were referring to only certain types of trees as being propagable.

I'll leave this thread in only saying you are obviously knowledgeable, however your posting was not as informative as you probably intended. As being such, I commented on it. I had no intention of belittling you, so there was no need for hostility. Take care and grow well.

It is hard as hell, but it can be done. So, you are in fact, incorrect...

Propagating Deciduous and Evergreen Shrubs, Trees and Vines with Stem Cuttings

this should help some of you. I have in fact propagated (from cuttings) a japanese black pine. Three plants from twenty cuttings. It was no easy task, and I had them in a highly sterile environment.

yes, cloned a pine.. but didn't want to help your cause.

__________________
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnZb5wi_jsU&NR=1